Heathcliff vs Edgar: Rivalry for Catherine

Traces the bitter rivalry between Heathcliff and Edgar for Catherine's love, leading to open hostility and tragedy.

increasingBearing stren­gth in each eventdecreasing

The Rivals Emerge

Two Worlds Collide Edgar's Courtship Edgar begins visiting Wuthering Heights, drawn to Catherine. Heathcliff is jealous and resentful. He sees Edgar as a weak, pampered rival. Catherine is torn between them. The Marked Calendar Heathcliff marks the days Catherine spends with the Lintons versus those with him. He confronts her, and she accuses him of being dull company. This shows the growing rift. Catherine's Choice Catherine chooses Edgar, but she does not abandon Heathcliff. She believes she can have both. This impossible situation sets the stage for conflict.

Open Hostility

The Breaking Point The Kitchen Confrontation Heathcliff and Edgar nearly come to blows in the kitchen. Catherine locks the door, forcing them to confront each other. Edgar strikes Heathcliff, who threatens to kill him. Edgar's Ultimatum Edgar demands that Catherine choose between him and Heathcliff. She refuses and locks herself in her room. This leads to her illness and death. Aftermath After Catherine's death, the enmity continues. Edgar bans Heathcliff from the Grange. Heathcliff marries Isabella to spite Edgar. Their conflict extends to the next generation.

The Final Victory

Heathcliff's Triumph The Forced Marriage Heathcliff forces Cathy to marry Linton, thereby gaining control of Thrushcross Grange. Edgar dies knowing his daughter is in Heathcliff's power. Hollow Victory Heathcliff's revenge is complete, but he finds no satisfaction. He is haunted by Catherine and loses interest in life. His victory is pyrrhic. Resolution After Heathcliff's death, the conflict ends. Hareton and Cathy unite the two families. The rivalry is finally laid to rest.

1778-1783

1783

1801