Myshkin's Inner Conflict: Love vs. Pity

The Idiot

Myshkin's struggle between his romantic love for Aglaya and his compassionate pity for Nastasya.

increasingupBearing stren­gth in each eventdowndecreasing
Meeting NastasyaMeeting Nastasya
Meeting Nastasya First Sight Myshkin sees Nastasya's portrait and feels a deep pity for her. He decides to help her. The Birthday Party He proposes to her out of pity, not love, which confuses his feelings.
Love for AglayaLove for Aglaya
Love for Aglaya Growing Affection Myshkin falls in love with Aglaya. He is torn between his pity for Nastasya and his love for Aglaya. The Green Bench Meetings He meets Aglaya secretly, but cannot abandon Nastasya.
The ChoiceThe Choice
The Choice Aglaya vs. Nastasya When forced to choose, Myshkin's pity for Nastasya overrides his love for Aglaya. He stays with Nastasya, leading to disaster. Aftermath He loses both women and his sanity.
early in the novel
during the summer
the confrontation scene