The Contrast Between Scrooge and Fred

The opposing philosophies of life represented by Scrooge's miserliness and Fred's generosity.

increasingBearing stren­gth in each eventdecreasing

Scrooge's Philosophy

The Miser's View Christmas as Humbug Scrooge sees Christmas as a time for paying bills and finding oneself poorer. He believes that only fools are merry. The Isolation Scrooge's philosophy leads to loneliness. He has no friends, no family warmth, and no joy.

Fred's Philosophy

The Optimist's View Christmas as a Good Time Fred believes Christmas is a time for kindness and charity. He says it has done him good, even without material gain. The Community Fred's philosophy fosters connection. He has a loving wife, friends, and a happy home. His life is rich in relationships.

The Resolution

Scrooge Embraces Fred's Way The Adoption of Joy Scrooge learns to keep Christmas well, joining Fred's party and becoming generous. He adopts Fred's philosophy of life. The Happy Ending The contrast is resolved: Scrooge chooses connection over isolation, joy over misery. The theme is that generosity brings happiness.

Christmas Eve, afternoon

Christmas Eve, afternoon

Christmas Day, after transformation