Howard McGill
A Woman of SubstanceHoward McGill, the twelve-year-old son of Paul McGill, is a largely offstage character whose care and isolation shape Paul’s private life and whose connection with Daisy offers a rare opening into his world. The novel presents him chiefly through Paul’s account: a boy who needs continuous support, is loved by his father, and responds to Daisy in a way that touches both adults.
Identity and Circumstances
Paul explains that Howard has an intellectual disability. Although twelve, he has the mental capacity of a five-year-old, and Paul believes his condition will not change. Paul describes him as a lovely-looking boy with gentle eyes, but the contrast between his appearance and his limited understanding sharpens the father’s sense of helplessness rather than easing it.
Howard lives at a sheep station in Coonamble, where a male companion-nurse is devoted to him. Paul’s housekeeper and a large domestic staff are also there to support his care. When Paul is at Dunoon, he spends a great deal of time with his son, though he doubts Howard truly recognizes his presence. Paul imagines him as inhabiting a world of his own, a description that conveys both the distance between them and the limits of what his father can reach.
Paul’s Love and Burden
Howard’s condition is one of the personal truths Paul has found difficult to discuss. He admits to Emma that he loves his son, aches for him, and feels enormous guilt; he also confesses that frustration and despair sometimes give rise to feelings of resentment. He is ashamed of those feelings and has never disclosed them to anyone else. Emma responds without condemning him, recognizing the distress behind the confession.
Howard’s needs also help explain why Paul’s return to England was delayed. After Paul’s father died, his wife, Constance, became seriously ill; just as Paul thought he might leave, Howard fell sick. Paul says he was able to travel only after Howard recovered. The account makes Howard’s circumstances part of the practical demands that bind Paul to his family as well as an emotional burden he has carried largely in silence.
Bond with Daisy
When Daisy is five, Paul insists that she accompany him and Emma to Australia. After a week in Sydney, they travel to Coonamble and spend four weeks at Dunoon. There, an unexpected rapport develops between Daisy and her half brother. She seems to reach Howard in a way no one else has, while his dependence on her and her devotion to him move Paul and Emma.
The visit becomes a recurring family journey: Paul takes Emma and Daisy back every year, unwilling to deprive Howard of the happiness his young half sister brings him. Daisy’s companionship does not alter the account of Howard’s disability, but it changes the meaning of his isolation. The relationship gives him a close family connection that Paul and Emma can witness, and it gives Paul a concrete reason to sustain the visits.
Narrative Significance
Howard’s character is developed through contrast: Paul’s anguish and uncertainty stand beside the devoted care provided at the station, while Howard’s limited independence is set against the warmth of his bond with Daisy. The novel does not give him an extended independent voice in these episodes; instead, his life is conveyed through the people who care for him and the effect he has on them. That framing makes him central to Paul’s concealed grief and guilt, yet also associates him with tenderness, family attachment, and the possibility of connection across profound differences in understanding.


