The Boatman’s Anger
Across the River and into the TreesThis flow traces the boatman’s hostility toward Cantwell, from a tense working relationship to an explanation rooted in wartime violence.
increasing
Bearing strength in each event
decreasing
A Cold Welcome

A Cold Welcome
Hostility at the blind
The boatman responds tersely when Cantwell asks about water and the shooting location. His anger is visible in the way he breaks ice and scatters decoys.
Misread motives
Cantwell thinks the man is simply surly and tries to keep the day from being spoiled. He has not yet learned what the Allied uniform means to the boatman.
A Boundary Broken

A Boundary Broken
The forbidden shot
The boatman fires at ducks heading toward Cantwell’s blind, a serious breach of their shared sporting arrangement. Cantwell recognizes the act as deliberate and personal.
Anger contained by distance
Cantwell fires warning shots because he cannot reach the boatman with a shout. The confrontation remains unresolved while both men stay at their posts.
A Bitter Exchange

A Bitter Exchange
Few words
The boatman remarks that Cantwell shot few ducks, and Cantwell replies that the man helped ensure it. Their exchange is brief but plainly accusatory.
A changed manner
By the return trip, the boatman’s anger has given way to satisfaction. Cantwell does not demand an explanation yet, leaving room for a different account of the hostility.
The Story of the Family

The Story of the Family
An explanation from Alvarito
Alvarito tells Cantwell that Moroccan troops raped the boatman’s wife and daughter when they passed through the area. The man’s reaction to the Allied uniform becomes intelligible.
No easy defense
The explanation does not erase the harm done to Cantwell’s hunt, but it makes his grievance seem small beside the boatman’s trauma. Cantwell answers by asking for a drink.
A Shared Drink

A Shared Drink
An offered flask
Earlier on the return journey, Cantwell offers the boatman grappa, and the man accepts it. They speak about the shooting without escalating the dispute.
A fragile human contact
The drink does not solve their conflict, but it creates a brief moment of mutual courtesy. The later explanation shows how little either man could know about the other’s wounds during the hunt.
Before daylight on the first hunt
Later in the same morning’s hunt
As the boatman rows Cantwell back through the ice
After the hunt, inside the lodge
During the boat ride back from the blind