Henry and Bill as Colleagues

All the Old Knives

Henry’s professional respect for Bill turns into a coercive interrogation that exposes how the investigator has become part of the wrongdoing.

increasing

Bearing strength in each event

decreasing

A Shared Station A Shared Station from "All the Old Knives". A Shared Station Work Henry and Bill serve in the same station, with Bill as Celia’s senior colleague and Henry working sources in the field.

A Shared Station from "All the Old Knives". A Shared Station Work Henry and Bill serve in the same station, with Bill as Celia’s senior colleague and Henry working sources in the field.

A Shared Station Work Henry and Bill serve in the same station, with Bill as Celia’s senior colleague and Henry working sources in the field. Their professional worlds overlap during the crisis. Distance They share institutional loyalties but not equal knowledge of each other’s private choices. That imbalance will matter when Henry later decides who to accuse.

A Crisis Without Answers A Crisis Without Answers from "All the Old Knives". A Crisis Without Answers Suspicion The station recognizes that Ahmed’s final messages may indicate a leak.

A Crisis Without Answers from "All the Old Knives". A Crisis Without Answers Suspicion The station recognizes that Ahmed’s final messages may indicate a leak.

A Crisis Without Answers Suspicion The station recognizes that Ahmed’s final messages may indicate a leak. Bill and others consider outside explanations as well as the possibility of an insider. Silence The leadership does not present a full account to later investigators. The absence of a clear explanation leaves colleagues exposed to suspicion and self-protection.

The London Interview The London Interview from "All the Old Knives". The London Interview Pressure Henry approaches Bill in London and questions him about the old crisis.

The London Interview from "All the Old Knives". The London Interview Pressure Henry approaches Bill in London and questions him about the old crisis.

The London Interview Pressure Henry approaches Bill in London and questions him about the old crisis. He uses fear and implication to make Bill talk rather than offering the man a fair account of the evidence. Distortion Bill’s distress gives Henry information but also allows the investigator to steer the conversation toward his chosen suspects. Their old colleague relationship has become adversarial.

The Phone Line Accusation The Phone Line Accusation from "All the Old Knives". The Phone Line Accusation Evidence Henry presents the call from Bill’s office line as suspicious and asks why Celia concealed the records.

The Phone Line Accusation from "All the Old Knives". The Phone Line Accusation Evidence Henry presents the call from Bill’s office line as suspicious and asks why Celia concealed the records.

The Phone Line Accusation Evidence Henry presents the call from Bill’s office line as suspicious and asks why Celia concealed the records. He gives Bill reason to believe that his own career and home life are at risk. Projection Henry is using evidence connected to his own actions to pressure others. The accusation is therefore also a projection of his concealed guilt.

A Warning Instead of Revenge A Warning Instead of Revenge from "All the Old Knives". A Warning Instead of Revenge Concern After the interview, Bill understands that Henry may be targeting Celia.

A Warning Instead of Revenge from "All the Old Knives". A Warning Instead of Revenge Concern After the interview, Bill understands that Henry may be targeting Celia.

A Warning Instead of Revenge Concern After the interview, Bill understands that Henry may be targeting Celia. He chooses to warn her rather than confront Henry publicly. Relationship The call demonstrates that their colleague bond has not disappeared, even as the investigation makes Bill a potential witness against Henry.

During their Vienna years

December 2006, after the mass killing

About one month before October 16, 2012

During the London interview

Two weeks before October 16, 2012