The Campaign’s Defeat
Black Water (Joyce Carol Oates Edition)This flow follows Kelly Kelleher’s political confidence from campaign work to personal collapse and her later effort to keep faith with public life.
increasing
Bearing strength in each event
decreasing
Faith in the Campaign

A Volunteer’s Confidence
Work for a candidate
Kelly Kelleher gives time and energy to Governor Dukakis’s presidential campaign. She expects voters to recognize the opposition’s faults and respond to her candidate’s arguments.
A larger conviction
Her confidence is more than campaign enthusiasm; it rests on a belief that political judgment can reflect moral judgment. That belief makes defeat especially difficult to absorb.
Warnings Unheard

Optimism Against Polls
Evidence resisted
National polls indicate that the campaign is in trouble, but Kelly Kelleher and her coworkers fail to accept how likely defeat has become.
A painful blind spot
She later sees that her judgment was not as clear as she believed. Her political experience becomes a lesson in how hope can prevent people from recognizing approaching loss.
The Election Loss

The Unthinkable Result
A landslide
When the votes come in, the Republican victory becomes undeniable. What Kelly Kelleher had regarded as impossible turns into ordinary political history.
The collapse of certainty
The result forces her to reconsider the connection between what seems self-evident to her and what the electorate chooses. Her idealism survives, but its confidence is shaken.
A Call to Her Mother

Asking to Be Found
Grief in the body
Kelly Kelleher barely eats or sleeps and wanders through Boston in a state of confusion. The political result has become a personal crisis rather than a distant disappointment.
A request for rescue
She telephones Madelyn Kelleher and asks her to come because she no longer knows where she is. The moment reveals the care beneath their disagreements.
Politics Remains

Returning to Public Work
Continuing commitment
Despite the campaign’s defeat and her disillusionment, Kelly Kelleher still writes for Citizens' Inquiry Foundation and remains interested in political change.
A complicated inheritance
Her meeting with The Senator revives her hopes while exposing the risk of investing too much in public figures. Political belief remains alive, but no longer appears immune to disappointment.
The months before the 1988 election
The final weeks of the campaign
Election night in 1988
Days after the election
By the Fourth of July, several years later