The Senator and Ray Annick's Friendship
Black Water (Joyce Carol Oates Edition)The Senator and Ray Annick’s friendship links a long-standing personal acquaintance to the practical alliance of political and legal life. Ray, a lawyer and schoolmate of The Senator at Andover, is present with him at the Fourth of July gathering and plays tennis on his team; after the crash, The Senator turns to him as the person who can come and retrieve him. The call reveals the bond’s urgency, but also its limits: as The Senator begins to frame the accident as a threat to his future, Ray insists on locating him rather than discussing the crisis over the telephone.
History and Place in Their Circle
Ray is described as The Senator’s lawyer-friend and as a man who went to school with him at Andover. The relationship therefore predates the events of the Fourth of July, although the available account does not specify how often they saw one another or what their friendship was like in private. Ray is also Buffy St. John’s lover, placing him within the same social circle as Kelly Kelleher and the Senator during the party. He introduces Kelly to The Senator that afternoon, a small act that connects their established circle to the chance encounter at the center of the evening’s events.
The introduction matters because Kelly initially regards The Senator with reserve. She sees him shaking hands with guests in a breathless, campaign-like manner and privately thinks of him as one of the political class, perpetually campaigning. Ray’s presence supplies the bridge between the famous public figure and a young woman who has only just met him. The narrative is careful about the chronology: Kelly and The Senator are new acquaintances that day, not established lovers or prior companions. Ray’s role in bringing them together is real, but it does not make him a witness to a longer relationship between them.
Shared Activities Before the Crash
The Senator and Ray appear together in a comparatively ordinary setting on the tennis court. They gamely and good-naturedly pair up in doubles against younger opponents. The Senator’s height and ease of movement distinguish him: he plays with the territorial confidence of someone instructed from boyhood, conserves his energy, and places difficult shots with precision. Ray is his teammate in this public display, while the young women watching admire the play and take photographs. The match gives the friendship a visible, companionable form, without suggesting that Ray is merely an aide or a political subordinate.
Later, Ray’s connection to the group also helps establish the setting for the crisis. The Senator and Kelly leave the party at 17 Derry Road at about 7:55 p.m., hoping to reach the ferry in time. They have roughly twenty-five minutes, enough if they drive fast and take the correct route. The Senator turns onto Old Ferry Road, a badly rutted marsh road no longer maintained by Grayling Township and one that should have been officially closed. The mistaken turn is described as understandable even without alcohol; the account does not establish that Ray was in the car or that he caused the route choice. Instead, Ray remains at the party, where his presence will soon make him the person The Senator tries to reach.
The Call After the Accident
After the Toyota leaves the road and enters Indian Creek, The Senator escapes the sinking car and struggles through the marsh toward the highway. He reaches a public telephone booth at the Post Beer & Wine parking lot, filthy, bruised, limping with one shoe on and one shoe off. The ordeal has left him in visceral panic. He fears being discovered and recognized, and his thoughts turn not only to the accident but to his political prospects: nomination, election, enemies, and public disgrace. He vows that he will remain sober, but the immediate need is to summon help.
At first, he calls the St. John residence under the name Gerald Ferguson, using the identity of a legal associate who would be more likely to call Ray at that hour. Ray answers the line only after the person who takes the call goes to fetch him. His initial response is wary: Ferguson is no friend, and a call at such a time suggests trouble. When The Senator reveals himself, Ray recognizes that something serious has happened and asks what accident he means. The Senator says that the girl is dead. Ray’s stunned repetition of the news is followed immediately by a practical instruction: he tells The Senator not to explain over the phone, asks where he is, and promises to come get him.
Loyalty, Fear, and the Limits of the Record
Ray’s response is decisive but narrowly focused on the immediate emergency. He does not invite a detailed account over a telephone line; instead, he tries to establish The Senator’s location and arrange to retrieve him. The Senator, by contrast, is already speaking in the language of anticipated blame and political consequence. He says Kelly was drunk, became emotional, grabbed at the wheel, and caused the car to swerve, then fears that others will call the death manslaughter. Those claims are The Senator’s account in a moment of panic, not an independently established finding about how the crash happened. The road’s disuse and dangerous condition are also part of the circumstances, while a possible collision with a bridge is presented only as speculation.
This distinction gives the friendship’s crisis its tension. Ray is a lawyer-friend who can provide help, but the scene does not show him affirming The Senator’s explanation or planning a legal defense. His sharp interruption redirects the exchange from accusation and prediction to the concrete question of where The Senator is. The Senator then gives him the location. At 9:55 p.m., the digital numerals on The Senator’s Rolex mark the call in the night’s chronology. Kelly, meanwhile, cannot know about the conversation: the narrative returns to her experience of the drive as if the accident has not yet happened, while the reader has already seen The Senator seek Ray’s help.
Narrative Significance
The relationship is defined here less by a full portrait of private friendship than by the different pressures under which it appears. On the tennis court, the two men share a team and a good-natured contest; at the party, Ray’s introduction of Kelly connects the group; after the crash, he becomes the person The Senator calls when alone and desperate. That movement from leisure to emergency makes the old school connection newly consequential without establishing more than the text shows.
The phone call also contrasts the two men’s immediate concerns. Ray refuses to let a potentially consequential account unfold over the phone and concentrates on finding The Senator. The Senator’s first explanation, however, shifts blame toward Kelly and imagines the legal and political consequences for himself. The friendship provides a lifeline, but it does not erase the moral imbalance of the scene: Kelly is dead or believed dead, and Ray hears about her death through the man who has escaped the car. The novel thus presents their bond at the point where personal loyalty, legal caution, and political self-preservation begin to overlap, leaving the extent of Ray’s later involvement unstated.