Readify

The Bond Between Yehoshua and the Tailor

City of God

A fake grandfather and a borrowed grandson form a kinship of daily care and mutual learning in the ghetto.

increasingupBearing stren­gth in each eventdowndecreasing
The Bogus GrandfatherThe Bogus Grandfather from "City of God". The Bogus Grandfather Context A frightened woman from the council brings Yehoshua to the tailor Srebnitsky and introduces them as grandfather and grandson.
The Bogus Grandfather Context A frightened woman from the council brings Yehoshua to the tailor Srebnitsky and introduces them as grandfather and grandson. The old man is skeptical, ill-tempered, and smells of must. Yet he accepts the boy into his two-room house, mends his clothes, and gives him a place to sleep. Significance The relationship is based on a lie that becomes a form of truth. Srebnitsky owes the boy nothing, but he takes him in because the council has decreed it. The boy quickly learns that the tailor's hands, though old, are the most alive part of him. Consequences Yehoshua begins to study the tailor as a craftsman and as a thinker. The house on Demokratu Street becomes a temporary home.
Bible Lessons from a SkepticBible Lessons from a Skeptic from "City of God". Bible Lessons from a Skeptic Context The only book in Srebnitsky's house is a Bible, and Yehoshua begins to read it closely.
Bible Lessons from a Skeptic Context The only book in Srebnitsky's house is a Bible, and Yehoshua begins to read it closely. When he asks questions, the old man responds with a skeptic's delight, pointing out contradictions, impossible dates, and pious frauds. He tells the boy that the people who made up the stories knew less than they did. Significance Srebnitsky's anti-theodicy is both a philosophy and a survival strategy. He does not need God to justify the world; he needs his own craft and contempt. The boy is oddly comforted, inheriting a faith in reason that will serve him in the ghetto and after. Consequences Yehoshua learns to question everything. The bond with the tailor deepens as a shared intellectual resistance to the world as it is.
The Sewing Machine ReturnThe Sewing Machine Return from "City of God". The Sewing Machine Return Context Srebnitsky receives a bolt of luxurious cloth and his confiscated sewing machine so he can make a uniform for S.S.
The Sewing Machine Return Context Srebnitsky receives a bolt of luxurious cloth and his confiscated sewing machine so he can make a uniform for S.S. Major Schmitz. He works in anger, muttering to himself. Yehoshua watches his hands and understands part of the old man's rage: his skills are being used to dress the enemy. Significance The uniform commission forces Srebnitsky into a degrading intimacy with the Nazi commandant. The boy feels the sting of his fake grandfather's compromised labor. Their bond is tested by the emasculating necessity of the work. Consequences The crisis builds toward Srebnitsky's fatal slash. Yehoshua is present to witness both the commission and the rebellion.
Watching the Old Man FallWatching the Old Man Fall from "City of God". Watching the Old Man Fall Context From the entrance to an alley, Yehoshua watches the driver club Srebnitsky to the ground and kick him.
Watching the Old Man Fall Context From the entrance to an alley, Yehoshua watches the driver club Srebnitsky to the ground and kick him. The old man's hands, once nimble instruments, are mangled and bleeding. Yehoshua runs to him, but a neighbor pulls him away, telling him that Srebnitsky is finished and he must flee. Significance The brutal image marks Yehoshua's childhood forever. He carries guilt for having run away, though he was only a child. The bond with Srebnitsky is burned into him as the sight of a man who chose to fight back. Consequences Yehoshua becomes a runner for the council, carrying the old man's memory as an amulet of defiance.
A Grandson's Final GiftA Grandson's Final Gift from "City of God". A Grandson's Final Gift Context At the gallows, Srebnitsky seems to lift his head and read his glory into the scene.
A Grandson's Final Gift Context At the gallows, Srebnitsky seems to lift his head and read his glory into the scene. Yehoshua stands in the crowd, carrying the old man's memory. Decades later he tells his daughter that what lingers is not the heroism but the ordinary care: the let-out seams, the new shoes, the silent meals. Significance The bond resolves into love that has no word. Srebnitsky's self-sacrifice was for a community, but his daily kindnesses were for one boy. Memory transforms the hanging itself into a gift. Consequences Yehoshua inherits the tailor's iconoclasm and his defiant hands, if not his craft. The invented grandson becomes the real one by accepting the inheritance.
when Yehoshua is first placed with Srebnitsky
during the winter months in the tailor's shop
when Schmitz commissions the uniform and the sewing machine is returned
the morning of Schmitz's uniform pickup
at the hanging and in years of later reflection