Michal and Zehava’s Chosen Family
Here There Is No WhyA mother-daughter bond between Michal and Zehava grows from care and trust into shared secrecy after Chaim’s death.
increasing
Bearing strength in each event
decreasing
A Second Mother

A Second Mother
Care in the gaps
Zehava teaches Michal practical and personal skills that Michal feels she did not receive from her own mother. She calls the girl her daughter, offering attention that makes Michal feel deeply cherished.
A family bond forms
The relationship grows alongside Michal’s closeness to Yoav and the Lerner household. It gives Zehava a daughter-like attachment and gives Michal a source of affection beyond her biological family.
A Private Confidence

A Private Confidence
A request for help
Zehava repeatedly asks Michal to visit Yoav in the hospital after his shooting of two children. Michal initially refuses, but eventually returns to the young man she has loved since childhood.
Loyalties revealed
Zehava’s insistence shows how much she trusts Michal with her family’s most painful crisis. Michal’s return will lead her away from Judah and toward a marriage shaped by care as well as love.
A Wedding Dress

A Wedding Dress
A shared errand
Zehava and Michal shop for a wedding dress as Michal prepares to marry Yoav. The outing gives the police a seemingly solid alibi for the night of Chaim’s death.
Evidence with limits
Receipts confirm a purchase but conceal an earlier fitting. The later discovery exposes how a reliable memory and a real document can still be used to sustain an incomplete account.
A Secret Protected

A Secret Protected
A confession with conditions
Zehava tells Judah that she pushed Chaim while resisting a blow, then asks him to protect her political future by withholding the confession. She frames silence as necessary for a chance at peace.
Loyalty beyond the facts
Her account also reflects her devotion to Michal. Zehava has helped hide Michal’s role, reinforcing a family bond that outlasts the marriage and the public story of Chaim’s death.
The Funeral Bench

The Funeral Bench
A truth finally spoken
Michal meets Judah beside Charlie’s grave and explains that Zehava forbade her from telling him what happened. With Zehava dead, the old secrecy can finally be broken.
Grief and gratitude
Michal remembers Zehava as a second mother and protector. Her disclosure deepens Judah’s understanding of both women, making affection and complicity difficult to separate.
During Michal’s adolescence
1982, after Yoav’s crisis in Lebanon
May 1983, around the night Chaim dies
July 2005, when Zehava speaks with Judah
September 2023, after Zehava’s funeral