Marriage
Here There Is No WhyMarriage in the novel is neither a reliable shelter from history nor a simple happy ending. It binds private love to family duty, wartime injury, inherited trauma, and religious custom. Across Chaim and Zehava, Michal and Yoav, Hannah, and Judah Loeb’s eventual marriage to Liora, the institution changes meaning: it can hide pain, demand a choice between loves, preserve family ritual, or make room for a future without erasing loss.
Marriage and family life
The novel presents marriage through several generations, but not every important love becomes a marriage. Judah’s early relationship with Michal is intense and formative; his later life with Mary becomes the enduring love against which he understands that first attachment. His account of those relationships is not a simple ranking: Michal belongs to youthful longing and discovery, while Mary is the partner with whom he builds a family and raises Hannah. The contrast gives the later marriage plot its emotional history. For Judah, adulthood does not cancel the first love, and a lasting partnership does not make earlier attachments meaningless.
Mary’s past relationships also enter the story through the couple’s candid conversations. Shortly before her death, she tells Judah about Mark, her high-school sweetheart in Cleveland Heights, Ohio, whom she might have married had they been older; Barry, her summer-stock co-star in Pippin; and Steve, a University of Chicago physicist whose depression led to hospitalization after their breakup. She asks Judah not only for the names of former partners but for the shape and meaning of his romantic past. Their conversation makes intimacy part of a shared life story: each tries to understand how prior attachments fit into the present. It also places their partnership under the knowledge that Mary’s illness will make their time together finite.
Chaim and Zehava: public family, private strain
Chaim and Zehava’s marriage carries a sharper division between what outsiders see and what the household endures. Judah encounters Chaim as a generous, witty teacher, a man whose charm is freely extended to students. Zehava later describes that charm as something Chaim deliberately spent on his pupils, including Judah. Her account complicates Judah’s idealized view of the man and exposes how little a student’s experience can reveal about a spouse’s life.
Zehava traces the marriage’s concealed distress to Chaim’s recurring nightmares. They began ten years into the marriage, when Yoav was eight, and continued almost nightly for close to three years. Between one and three in the morning, Chaim kicked, groaned, and cursed in Polish. Zehava says she could neither soothe him nor wake him. Her recollection makes the marriage a place where Holocaust trauma entered ordinary nights and affected the child growing up within the household. Its strain was not visible in Judah’s warm conversations with Chaim; Zehava’s testimony supplies the intimate history his admiration had missed.
Marriage also gives the family a structure that persists after Chaim’s death. At Zehava’s Friday-night table, Yoav sits at the head and leads the Kiddush blessing in a colorful Yemenite yarmulke. Chaim, although secular, had led the traditional Sabbath Eve rituals as the man of the house; after he is gone, the task falls to his son. The transfer does not establish that every difficulty in the family has been resolved. Instead, it shows a customary role passing from father to son, with family continuity carried through a meal and a blessing.
Michal and Yoav: love, choice, and separation
Michal and Yoav’s marriage grows out of a history that predates Judah’s arrival. They were schoolmates and neighbors, shared a youth group, and became high-school sweethearts and serious young adult lovers. Their relationship breaks when Yoav applies for officer training. Michal objects to the additional danger and separation, but especially to the prospect of his deeper involvement in the Lebanon conflict. After their argument, he does not call back; she believes the relationship has ended and begins seeing Judah.
The rupture does not extinguish her love for Yoav. When Zehava tells her that he has shot two ten-year-old boys in Lebanon and has been admitted to a military psychiatric ward in Haifa, Michal initially refuses to visit. Zehava keeps asking, invoking a bond in which she has long treated Michal as a daughter. Michal eventually goes to the hospital, sees Yoav helpless, and recognizes that she still loves him. She tells Judah that she loves both men but must choose, and acknowledges that her love for Yoav is stronger. The engagement announcement that follows turns that private choice into a family event: Chaim returns to the balcony grinning, Zehava embraces him, and the couple tell Judah that their son is engaged to Michal.
Judah’s own involvement with Michal ends in a painful, incomplete farewell. Three days before his scheduled departure, he visits her intending to say goodbye. Rather than discuss his leaving, she draws him into the apartment and initiates their first intercourse. For Judah, it is his first sexual experience and part of the first love he will remember with exactness; for the relationship, it is not a reversal of Michal’s choice. The next morning he weeps while holding her. She tells him Yoav will arrive soon, pushes away his attempt at a farewell embrace, and does not answer his declaration of love. The intimacy briefly deepens the bond while making its limit unmistakable.
Years later, Michal tells Judah that Yoav moved out six months earlier and that they are getting divorced. She says she is free, suggesting that their separation might change what is possible between her and Judah. He nevertheless says goodbye. The novel does not present the divorce as an automatic second chance: their past remains consequential, and Judah’s refusal to resume the relationship keeps their earlier farewell in force.
Hannah’s adulthood and Judah’s later marriage
Marriage becomes part of Hannah’s adult life as well. After receiving books from Kaplowitz, she develops an interest in Jewish spirituality and later tells Judah she intends to become a rabbi. She marries a millionaire software engineer she meets on JDate. The account offers little detail about the couple’s courtship, but it establishes Hannah as someone who forms a family of her own while pursuing a religious vocation. She later has a daughter, and her work as a rabbi will bring those strands together in her father’s wedding ceremony.
Judah’s own later marriage to Liora arrives after years of loss and separation. Hannah is present, along with her husband and daughter, when Judah marries Liora on the eighth night of Hanukkah in 2023. The ceremony takes place under a huppah made from four poles and Judah’s late father’s wedding tallit. Liora wears a tallit of her own, and Hannah, now a rabbi, reads their ketubah. Its promises include caring for one another in old age, a commitment the novel emphasizes as more than ceremonial language for two older people entering marriage.
The ceremony is built from modest, specific actions: Judah lifts Liora’s veil, they exchange rings, and they sip the sweet wine twice. He speaks his words of love in a shaky voice, with fear rather than mere nervousness; Liora answers in kind, and Hannah speaks and sings. Hannah then explains the breaking of the glass as an invitation to admit sorrow into a moment of great joy. Judah thinks of Mary, Michal, Yoav, Charlie, Israel, and Chaim. The wedding therefore does not resolve every earlier attachment or loss. It makes a new promise while keeping the broken world—and the people who remain part of his memory—present within the celebration.
Narrative significance
Marriage in the novel is measured less by an ideal of effortless permanence than by the obligations and histories it gathers. Chaim and Zehava’s domestic life is shadowed by trauma Judah cannot see; Michal and Yoav’s bond survives separation and wartime injury before ending in divorce; Hannah’s marriage accompanies her religious vocation; and Judah’s marriage to Liora makes care in old age an explicit promise. Across these different outcomes, family rituals recur even as their participants and meanings change. Yoav takes over the Sabbath blessing after his father’s death, and Hannah later leads Judah’s wedding. The final ceremony does not convert grief into a completed past: the broken glass gives sorrow a place inside joy, allowing marriage to signify both a new beginning and an honest acknowledgment of what cannot be restored.