Dewey’s Pursuit
In Cold BloodThis thread follows Alvin Dewey from personal commitment through investigative exhaustion to unresolved reflection.
increasing
Bearing strength in each event
decreasing
A Personal Obligation

A Personal Obligation
Friendship behind the badge
Alvin Adams Dewey knew Herbert William Clutter and Bonnie Clutter through the community. Their murders turn professional duty into a promise to discover what happened.
The case expands
He takes charge and assembles experienced investigators. The task quickly becomes a consuming search for a motive, a suspect, and a reliable chain of proof.
The Investigation’s Cost

The Investigation’s Cost
Exhaustion accumulates
Alvin Adams Dewey works long hours, smokes heavily, and loses weight as hundreds of tips lead nowhere. The unsolved case follows him home and disrupts family life.
Doubt persists
Even promising evidence leaves room for uncertainty. Dewey worries that the suspects may never be found or that the case may fail in court.
The Lead Arrives

The Lead Arrives
Wells’s account
Floyd Wells tells prison officials that Dick had described a plan involving Herbert William Clutter’s household. His information gives the investigators a route toward two suspects.
Cautious hope
Dewey receives the new names but does not treat the story as proof. He understands that the case still requires independent evidence and a confession or equivalent corroboration.
A Dream Before the Arrest

A Dream Before the Arrest
A pursuit imagined
Dewey dreams that he chases the suspects through familiar places, only to see them vanish amid the dead. The nightmare captures his fear that the case will remain beyond his reach.
News from Nye
Harold Nye soon reports that the suspects have resurfaced through forged checks. Dewey’s next steps are practical, but the dream’s helplessness stays with him.
No Simple Closure

No Simple Closure
Witness to execution
Alvin Adams Dewey attends the executions of Perry Smith and Dick. He believes the sentence was deserved, yet reacts differently to each man and especially remembers Perry’s vulnerability.
A quieter ending
Later, Dewey meets Susan Kidwell at the family graves. Their conversation links the finished legal case to a life that continued around the loss, rather than resolving the loss itself.
November 1959
November–December 1959
December 1959
Late December 1959
April 14, 1965