Allysa Kincaid's Two Loyalties

It Ends with Us

Follows Allysa Kincaid as she balances her love for her brother Ryle with her love for her best friend Lily Bloom.

increasing

Bearing strength in each event

decreasing

Searching for Purpose Searching for Purpose from "It Ends with Us". Searching for Purpose Scene Allysa Kincaid, a wealthy wife with no career, sees a help-wanted sign and walks into Lily's shop out of curiosity.

Searching for Purpose from "It Ends with Us". Searching for Purpose Scene Allysa Kincaid, a wealthy wife with no career, sees a help-wanted sign and walks into Lily's shop out of curiosity.

Searching for Purpose Scene Allysa Kincaid, a wealthy wife with no career, sees a help-wanted sign and walks into Lily's shop out of curiosity. She immediately offers to work for nearly nothing because she is bored. She ends up becoming the shop's heart and soul. Significance Allysa's boredom masks an emotional crisis: she is unable to get pregnant and has retreated from the pain of trying. Working at the shop gives her a daily reason to get dressed and care about something outside herself. Her friendship with Lily begins as mutual rescue. Aftermath Allysa introduces Lily to her brother Ryle by accident when he comes to help with a sprained ankle. The friendship becomes entangled with the novel's central love story.

Becoming Pregnant Becoming Pregnant from "It Ends with Us". Becoming Pregnant Scene After years of failed attempts, Allysa reveals she is pregnant in a crowded bar while wearing a onesie.

Becoming Pregnant from "It Ends with Us". Becoming Pregnant Scene After years of failed attempts, Allysa reveals she is pregnant in a crowded bar while wearing a onesie.

Becoming Pregnant Scene After years of failed attempts, Allysa reveals she is pregnant in a crowded bar while wearing a onesie. Marshall shouts the news at the top of his lungs. The joy of the moment is amplified by how long she had kept her grief hidden. Significance Allysa's pregnancy introduces a parallel family trajectory to Lily's own. It also gives Ryle a taste of fatherhood through his niece, stirring his desire to have a child. Allysa's happiness is genuine, but it is soon shadowed by her brother's violence toward Lily. Aftermath Allysa gives birth to Rylee and becomes a mother. The timing of the birth coincides with Lily's move into the new apartment and the beginning of the end of her marriage.

Sibling Confident and Defender

Sibling Confident and Defender Scene Allysa warns Lily about Ryle's track record, then fights with Ryle in the kitchen when he accuses her of undermining him. She knows his childhood trauma and his blackout rages, but she also loves him deeply. Her loyalty is constantly split between protecting Lily and shielding Ryle. Significance The sibling relationship reveals that no one is purely villain or victim. Allysa's fear for Lily is based on knowing Ryle better than anyone. Her early warning makes the later discovery of his abuse all the more devastating. Aftermath After Ryle attacks Lily, Allysa has to choose between blood and truth. She chooses Lily without ever stopping her love for Ryle.

Ultimatum as Best Friend Ultimatum as Best Friend from "It Ends with Us". Ultimatum as Best Friend Scene Allysa sits on the bed while Lily describes the assault, the hidden pregnancy, and her fear.

Ultimatum as Best Friend from "It Ends with Us". Ultimatum as Best Friend Scene Allysa sits on the bed while Lily describes the assault, the hidden pregnancy, and her fear.

Ultimatum as Best Friend Scene Allysa sits on the bed while Lily describes the assault, the hidden pregnancy, and her fear. She starts sobbing, then tells Lily that as her best friend she will never speak to her again if she goes back to Ryle. She immediately switches to helping her pick out maternity clothes. Significance The ultimatum is brutal, but it is the clearest act of love Lily receives from the Kincaid family. Allysa chooses the safety of her friend and unborn niece over loyalty to her brother. It allows Lily to trust that she will not lose her entire surrogate family if she leaves. Aftermath Allysa helps plan the baby shower, keeps Ryle’s distance, and becomes an aunt figure to Emerson. She remains a bridge between Lily and Ryle after the divorce.

Choosing Rylee's Name Choosing Rylee's Name from "It Ends with Us". Choosing Rylee's Name Scene Allysa and Marshall name their daughter Rylee, adding an E to Ryle's name.

Choosing Rylee's Name from "It Ends with Us". Choosing Rylee's Name Scene Allysa and Marshall name their daughter Rylee, adding an E to Ryle's name.

Choosing Rylee's Name Scene Allysa and Marshall name their daughter Rylee, adding an E to Ryle's name. They tell Ryle that they wanted to name her after someone they both think the world of. Ryle is visibly moved. Significance The naming cements Ryle's role as the uncle and near-namesake of the next generation. It makes his eventual fatherhood feel inevitable and makes his failure as a husband hurt more. Allysa’s gesture is also a reminder that she sees the good in him even when she cannot excuse the harm. Aftermath Rylee grows up alongside Emerson, and the two cousins form the family that Lily and Allysa sustain together. The name keeps Ryle close to Lily's world even after divorce.

when Allysa wanders into the dusty flower shop

at the onesie bar after the grand opening

from the morning after the party to the kitchen argument

when Lily confesses the truth about Ryle

right after Rylee's birth