Project Gutenberg License
Martin EdenThe Project Gutenberg License governs the use and redistribution of electronic works associated with Project Gutenberg. Its terms join a broad commitment to free access with conditions that preserve the license, regulate use of the Project Gutenberg name, and specify how copies may be shared or sold. The document also distinguishes public-domain works from works distributed with additional copyright terms and limits the remedies available when an electronic work has defects.
Purpose and Acceptance
The license presents acceptance as a condition of using the electronic work: reading or using any part signifies that the user has read, understood, and accepted the terms and the associated intellectual-property agreement. A user who does not accept them must stop using the work and return or destroy copies in their possession. If the user paid for access or a copy and declines the terms, the license provides for seeking a refund from the person or entity that received the payment, subject to the stated refund provision.
This requirement frames the work not simply as a free-standing file but as a work distributed under a set of conditions. The license’s opening terms connect access to compliance, while its later provisions describe ways to copy and share works without charge. Its free-access purpose therefore operates alongside rules about how that purpose and the Project Gutenberg name are carried forward.
Name, Copyright, and Sharing
Project Gutenberg is identified as a registered trademark, and the license restricts associating that name with an electronic work to people who agree to be bound by the terms. It also says that certain uses may be possible without complying with the full agreement, directing readers to the provisions governing those uses. For works derived from the public domain, the license states that nearly all individual works in the collection are public domain in the United States; for a public-domain work used by someone in the United States, it does not claim a right to prevent copying, distribution, performance, display, or the creation of derivative works, provided all references to Project Gutenberg are removed.
The license also offers a different route for sharing a work while retaining its connection to Project Gutenberg: the work should remain in the same format and carry the complete license when distributed without charge. This condition makes the attached terms part of the circulation of the electronic work, rather than optional information that can be detached from it. The document cautions that local copyright law governs what users may do, notes that copyright rules vary and change, and makes no representation about a work’s copyright status outside the United States.
Conditions for Redistribution
Where a work remains associated with Project Gutenberg, the license requires a prominent display of a specified notice, with active links or immediate access to the full license, whenever the work is accessed, displayed, performed, viewed, copied, or distributed. The terms also prohibit detaching or removing the full license from the work or from files containing part of it. Redistribution or other use of a work associated with Project Gutenberg must include the required notice and access to the full terms unless the distributor has removed all references to Project Gutenberg or has obtained permission under the license’s specified procedures.
The rules address format as well as attribution. A distributor may convert and distribute a work in binary, compressed, marked-up, proprietary, or other forms. If a copy is provided in a format other than the official Plain Vanilla ASCII or other format used on the official Project Gutenberg website, however, the distributor must provide, at no extra cost, the original format itself, a means of exporting a copy to it, or a means of obtaining it on request. Any alternate format must still include the complete license as specified by the redistribution provisions. These requirements preserve access to the original form while allowing technical adaptation.
Fees and Commercial Distribution
The license generally prohibits charging for access to, viewing, display, performance, copying, or distribution of Project Gutenberg works unless the distributor follows the stated exceptions or obtains permission. One exception allows a reasonable fee for copies or access, provided the distributor pays a royalty equal to 20 percent of gross profits calculated using the method already used for applicable taxes. The royalty is owed to the owner of the Project Gutenberg trademark, who has agreed to donate it to the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation; payment is due within 60 days after each date on which the distributor prepares, or is legally required to prepare, periodic tax returns.
This fee-based route also requires consumer protections. A distributor must offer a full refund to a user who gives written notice within 30 days of receipt that the user does not agree to the full license, and must require the return or destruction of physical copies and the discontinuation of other access. The terms separately provide for a refund or replacement copy if a defect is discovered and reported within 90 days. A distributor seeking to charge a fee or distribute a work on terms different from those specified must instead obtain written permission from both the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation and Michael Hart, identified in the license as the owner of the trademark.
Defects, Remedies, and Liability
The license recognizes that volunteer and employee efforts go into identifying works, researching copyright, transcription, and proofreading, but warns that electronic works and their storage media may nevertheless contain defects. Its examples include incomplete, inaccurate, or corrupted data, transcription errors, intellectual-property infringement, damaged media, viruses, and code that equipment cannot read or that damages it. The defect provision offers a limited remedy: within 90 days of receipt, a user may seek a refund by sending a written explanation to the provider; for a physical copy, the medium must be returned. The provider may offer a replacement instead, and a user who receives a second defective electronic copy may then demand a refund in writing.
Beyond that limited refund-or-replacement provision, the license disclaims other warranties and limits the remedies available for negligence, strict liability, breach of warranty, or breach of contract. It excludes liability for a range of damages and expenses, including direct, indirect, consequential, punitive, and incidental damages, while acknowledging that some jurisdictions do not permit every disclaimer or limitation. Where a provision conflicts with applicable state law, the terms direct that it be interpreted to allow the maximum limitation permitted by that law. The indemnity provision also places responsibility on users for liabilities and costs arising from their distribution, alteration, additions to or deletions from a work, or defects they cause.
Relationship to the Project Gutenberg Mission
The license describes Project Gutenberg as a free-distribution effort intended to make electronic works readable across a wide variety of computers, including obsolete, older, and newer machines. It attributes the collection’s existence to the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and to donations from people across society. That mission helps explain the agreement’s recurring concern with keeping works accessible in multiple formats while keeping the license attached and preserving the conditions for using the Project Gutenberg name.
The resulting arrangement is conditional rather than an unrestricted grant: the license makes broad forms of copying and distribution possible, especially for public-domain works in the United States, but ties continued association with Project Gutenberg to notices, intact terms, and limits on fees. Its separate provisions for copyright, technical formats, commercial use, defects, and liability define the practical boundaries of that commitment to free electronic access.