Readify

Zazen

Motherless Brooklyn

Zazen is the central seated practice of Zen Buddhism at the Yorkville Zendo, where it means more than a technique for relaxation: it is a demanding discipline organized around sitting and attention. For Lionel Essrog, first drawn toward it through Kimmery and then physically joining a session, the practice offers a striking counterpoint to his restless language and to the Zendo’s entanglement with secrets, surveillance, and violence.

Meaning and Instruction

Kimmery cautions Lionel against treating Buddhism as a means of getting centered or reducing stress. She describes it instead as a religious discipline, difficult in practice, and identifies zazen as its heart. Its name can be rendered as sitting, but that plain description does not make the practice easy: she warns that it will make a practitioner’s back hurt. Her eye-rolling sympathy gives the instruction a bodily emphasis, grounding an abstract religious idea in the discomfort of maintaining a posture.

When Lionel asks what there is to be good at, Kimmery explains the aim through the idea of One Mind: not thinking about not thinking, but not thinking about it, and recognizing that everything has Buddha nature. Her account includes the equivalence of flag and wind, a proposition Lionel only partly follows. He regards the ideal as honorable but perhaps chimerical, a response that registers both his interest and the distance between a verbal explanation and a discipline that must be practiced. Rather than claiming expertise, Kimmery admits she is not very good at sitting herself. She tells him that practice can be solitary or shared, and that regular sessions are held at the Yorkville Zendo.

Lionel Enters the Sitting Room

Lionel asks whether he may sit with Kimmery sometime; she invites him to stay that day. The Zendo is expecting important monks from Japan, one of whom is to speak after zazen. The visit therefore places his first practical encounter with the discipline amid institutional ceremony and heightened interest, not in a private lesson. Kimmery’s invitation is direct and inclusive: anyone can attend a session.

When Lionel returns, Kimmery welcomes him into a room where most of the practitioners are already seated. She tells him to take a cushion, sit away from the front, and concentrate on breathing; posture can wait. Her instruction reduces the immediate task to something manageable while presenting breathing as a practice that could occupy a lifetime. Lionel follows her upstairs, removes his shoes, and experiences the loss of street-readiness as both disconcerting and a relief to his aching feet.

The second-floor room is dim beneath unlit track lighting and fading November daylight. Incense smolders beside a jade Buddha; undecorated paper screens surround a glossy parquet floor laid with thin cushions. Kimmery guides Lionel to the back and demonstrates how to fold his legs and straighten his back. He struggles into position, jostles the practitioner ahead of him, and is met with a glare before the man returns to his poised posture. Lionel counts twenty-two practitioners, dressed in black robes or ordinary street clothes; he is conspicuous in his suit. These particulars make sitting a social and physical adjustment as well as an inward exercise: he must learn where to place his body among people whose practiced stillness he cannot yet share.

Stillness Against Inner and Outer Noise

Lionel tries to keep his back straight and concentrate, but the practice does not instantly quiet him. Beside Kimmery, whose eyes are peacefully shut, he becomes more conscious of his own language-generator: a crowded, involuntary tangle of responses and mimicry. Her presence feels like a tic-canceling field, yet that relief sharpens his awareness of the babble within him. Zazen thus gives the novel a concrete setting in which the difference between outward stillness and inward quiet becomes visible. Lionel can arrange his legs, follow a breath, and sit among others without thereby mastering his thoughts.

The discipline also sits beside another kind of listening. Elsewhere in the Zendo investigation, Frank Minna’s movements and conversations are monitored over a wire; a voice addresses him there, and later Frank whispers to Lionel through his microphone. That covert attention is practical and suspicious, aimed at acquiring information. Zazen’s attention is directed toward sitting and breathing. The contrast does not make the Zendo a refuge from the plot: it instead places practices of listening and silence beside the mechanisms of secrecy that surround the investigation.

Silence, Sesshin, and Interruption

At a later confrontation, Lionel tells the man he is facing that he has just broken his vow of silence. The man replies that his sesshin is finished and says Lionel brought silence to a conclusive end during that day’s sitting. The exchange distinguishes the broader period of intensive practice from the act of sitting within it, while showing that silence in this setting is a vow with limits and an ending, not a permanent condition. Lionel’s answer connects that ending to the investigation’s violence: he says the other man’s hired killer had something to do with it.

Zazen consequently remains both a discipline of attention and a setting in which stillness can be interrupted by the novel’s unresolved danger. Lionel’s participation begins with a modest instruction to breathe, amid cushions, incense, and Kimmery’s example; it ends in dialogue about a broken silence and a suspected killer. The distance between those moments gives the practice its narrative weight: sitting may orient the characters toward quiet, but it cannot seal the Zendo off from the acts and disclosures occurring around it.

Related StoryFlow