Carolyn Pearce's Tree House
P.S. I Still Love YouCarolyn Pearce's Tree House is a private neighborhood hideaway whose meaning rests in what it holds: years of shared childhood, friendships that have shifted, and a time capsule buried beneath it. First a place to talk and play, it becomes a setting for Lara Jean and Peter Kavinsky to revisit the past and for their old group to gather before the structure may be demolished. The tree house makes memory tangible, but its approaching disappearance gives that memory an urgent deadline.
Setting and Childhood Use
The tree house stood in the Pearces' backyard, close enough to Lara Jean's home that light from either house once reached it after dark. The familiar illumination is absent when Lara Jean and Peter climb up late one night: Peter goes first, then shines his phone flashlight down to help her. The change in light makes an old place feel newly unfamiliar, even as its interior remains just as they remember it.
The tree house had been a private gathering place for neighborhood children around Lara Jean's age, including Genevieve, Allie Feldman, Chris, Peter Kavinsky, John Ambrose McClaren, and Trevor Pike. They stopped using it in eighth grade, after which it was more or less abandoned; Kitty Covey had never shown much interest in coming up. Their time there was ordinary and companionable rather than transgressive. They sat and talked, and Genevieve devised hypothetical Who Would You Choose games that turned the group into an audience for one another's judgments.
One island-survival round preserves the group's different ways of seeing one another. Peter Kavinsky chose Genevieve because she was his girlfriend. Chris chose Trevor Pike for his size and obnoxiousness, reasoning that he might be useful if survival came to cannibalism. Lara Jean chose Chris because she would be entertaining and helpful. John Ambrose McClaren considered everyone's qualities before choosing Lara Jean, whom he imagined would keep hoping for rescue. The tree house thus holds not only a shared setting but early evidence of individual bonds and perceptions.
The Time Capsule and Return
The capsule began as an unwanted birthday present. John Ambrose McClaren received it from his grandmother in seventh grade after asking for a video game; when he considered throwing it away, Lara Jean said she wanted it. Genevieve and then Chris also expressed interest, and Lara Jean proposed burying it beneath the tree house. She asked everyone to contribute something they had with them at that moment and suggested they return after high-school graduation to open it and reminisce. The object made a future reunion part of the group's childhood plan.
Years later, Lara Jean remembers the capsule while sitting with Peter Kavinsky in the tree house. She suggests digging it up, and he readily agrees. The memory gives their visit a purpose beyond looking around: the structure's unchanged interior leads directly to a buried record of who they were. When Lara Jean learns that the retired Pearces may take the tree house down to make way for a gazebo, the old plan becomes newly pressing. The timing of demolition is uncertain, but the possibility is enough to make a proper farewell feel necessary.
Lara Jean decides to organize a themed party with Peter Kavinsky, Chris, Trevor Pike, and John Ambrose McClaren. She expects Genevieve to find the idea childish and chooses not to invite her. The planned food recreates the texture of the old summers: Cheez Doodles, ice-cream sandwiches, Hawaiian Punch, Capri Suns, and the peanut-butter-and-jelly sandwich John Ambrose McClaren used to bring in a plastic bag. Trevor Pike's portable speakers also belong to that remembered world, along with the story of Peter Kavinsky throwing them out of the tree house after Trevor played Sweet Home Alabama repeatedly. These details make the farewell an attempt to restore a specific social world, not simply to revisit a building.
Gathering, Games, and Significance
On the day of the gathering, Lara Jean digs beneath the tree with a shovel from the garage. The ground is hard, and she has to work before striking metal a couple of feet down. The capsule is about the size of a small cooler, shaped like a futuristic coffee thermos, and weathered by nearly four years of rain, snow, and dirt. She washes it in the kitchen sink until it gleams, carrying the recovered object from the buried past back into the present.
Close to noon, Lara Jean brings the snacks, portable speakers, and her phone across the backyard. John Ambrose McClaren is already standing before the tree house, looking up at it. She had expected Peter Kavinsky or Chris to arrive with her and ease any awkwardness; finding John alone makes her nervous. The reunion therefore begins with the same mixture of familiarity and changed relationships that the place contains. The tree house can gather its old occupants, but it cannot make them children again.
The capsule also becomes part of the gathering's present-day play. When Lara Jean has only one pen and no paper, John tears up the ice-cream-sandwich box so everyone can write names on cardboard scraps. The pieces go into the empty capsule, which Lara Jean shakes and passes around before drawing last. She finds John's name. The draw complicates the game for her: the childhood object that was meant to preserve a shared past now helps generate new uncertainty among the people who have returned.
The tree house's importance lies in this overlap of shelter, archive, and meeting place. Its interior can appear unchanged, while the former group's closeness, routines, and romantic attachments have altered. The threatened demolition gives their return a limit, and the capsule supplies a physical link between the children who promised to come back and the teenagers who do. The gathering cannot preserve the tree house indefinitely, but it lets its history be opened, handled, and briefly inhabited again.

