Bella and McCandless’s Uneven Courtship
Poor ThingsThis flow follows Archibald McCandless and Bella Baxter from fascination through separation and return to a working partnership.
increasing
Bearing strength in each event
decreasing
An Awkward First Meeting

An Awkward First Meeting
Attraction at first sight
McCandless meets Bella Baxter while she is learning to speak and explore the world. Her openness overwhelms his reserve, and he responds by kissing her hand.
A memory reinterpreted
His account treats the encounter as the beginning of his love. Bella later remembers the scene differently, reminding readers that affection can be real while recollection remains partial.
A Meeting at the Fountain

A Meeting at the Fountain
Recognition and desire
Bella Baxter returns to Glasgow more articulate and experienced, then singles out McCandless at the Loch Katrine Memorial Fountain. Their earlier attraction resumes in a more adult form.
Different emotional scales
McCandless experiences the meeting as a romantic revelation; Bella treats intimacy more freely and speaks openly about other lovers. Their bond begins with affection but not identical expectations.
A Promise and Its Delay

A Promise and Its Delay
Engagement imagined
McCandless proposes marriage, and Bella agrees while keeping her own understanding of time and commitment. Baxter asks them to wait, hoping to prepare himself for losing her.
Romantic idealization
McCandless writes ardent verses and cherishes small tokens as sacred pledges. Bella’s impatience with distance and convention exposes how far his idealized courtship differs from her lived experience.
A Separation Under Chloroform

A Separation Under Chloroform
A choice misunderstood
Bella Baxter chloroforms McCandless so she can leave with Duncan Wedderburn. Her note asks him to stay with Baxter, revealing that she means no simple rejection.
Love tested by absence
McCandless feels abandoned and grieves the future he had imagined. Instead of severing the bond, the separation exposes his dependence and gives Bella the experience that later changes her priorities.
A Shared Life

A Shared Life
Marriage negotiated
Bella returns with a stronger sense of her own aims and does not expect McCandless to obey her every wish. They establish affection through conversation, compromise, and chosen daily closeness.
Partnership beyond courtship
McCandless supports Bella’s medical education and public work. Their marriage becomes a practical alliance that accommodates ambition, tenderness, and separate lives.
Around 1881, at 18 Park Circus
After Bella’s world tour, at the West End Park fountain
1883, after the fountain meeting
1883, on the night Bella leaves with Wedderburn
After Bella’s return, from late 1883 onward