Gerry Adams and Martin McGuinness
Say NothingGerry Adams and Martin McGuinness were longstanding republican comrades whose partnership endured across the transition from armed conflict to electoral politics and government. The book presents their association less through private detail than through public acts: McGuinness’s defence of Adams during a politically sensitive arrest, their shared place in the peace process, and Adams’s later tribute at McGuinness’s grave. Together, those moments show a relationship rooted in the movement’s history but carried into a politics of compromise that neither erased nor settled the past.
Comrades in War and Political Transition
The book explicitly describes McGuinness as Adams’s longtime comrade in both war and peace. McGuinness had been a Derry gunman before becoming deputy first minister of Northern Ireland; Adams, too, survived the conflict and became the central political figure in a party that prospered on both sides of the border. Their trajectories make the partnership significant as more than a continuity of personal loyalty: it joined the republican movement’s armed past to its later electoral and governmental presence.
That transition took place against a history of entrenched division and discrimination. The account of the civil-rights movement describes Catholics as excluded from desirable employment and housing and denied executive power in Northern Ireland. The march from Belfast to Derry sought to challenge those conditions through peaceful protest, while violence and the failure of that strategy helped reshape the political choices available to republicans. The evidence does not identify that march as the beginning of Adams and McGuinness’s relationship; it establishes the turbulent political landscape in which their later shared passage from armed struggle into politics acquired its meaning.
The wider movement’s adoption of electoral politics was itself a consequential change. After hunger striker Bobby Sands stood for Parliament from prison, Adams embraced electoral campaigning while retaining a declared intention to boycott Westminster if elected. The book records Dolours Price campaigning for Adams in West Belfast, but it does not assign McGuinness a specific role in that campaign. In the relationship’s larger arc, such episodes mark the political environment in which the comrades’ later public partnership operated: electoral strategy and peace-making did not simply replace the past but developed within a movement shaped by it.
Alliance in Public Life
McGuinness’s support for Adams became conspicuous when Adams was arrested in a cold-case investigation concerning Jean McConville’s murder and secret burial. Overnight, artists painted a mural on the Falls Road showing a smiling Adams with the words PEACEMAKER, LEADER, VISIONARY. At the rally unveiling it, McGuinness called the arrest politically biased and argued that its timing could damage Sinn Féin in upcoming local-government and European elections. He blamed what he described as an embittered remnant of the former Royal Ulster Constabulary seeking to settle old scores.
The scene gave their alliance a political as well as personal dimension. Hundreds of supporters held signs defending the peace process and demanding Adams’s release, while McGuinness spoke beside Divis Tower. The defence presented the arrest not only as a case against an individual but as an attack on the party and its political standing. Yet the setting also carried a tension the book does not smooth away: the event celebrated Adams as a peacemaker while Bobby Storey, a former IRA enforcer and senior Sinn Féin figure, stood at McGuinness’s elbow holding his script. The public image of political transformation remained beside reminders of the movement’s armed history.
The book places this defence within a broader political climate in which former antagonists could find common ground. McGuinness and Adams were portrayed as able to negotiate with political opponents, including Ian Paisley, with whom McGuinness later worked closely in government. Paisley’s public acknowledgment that no one could obtain everything they desired captured the logic of compromise surrounding this period. The account does not reduce Adams and McGuinness’s relationship to a single cause or agreement; it shows their alliance operating within a political order increasingly reliant on negotiation, while old disputes and accusations remained active.
McGuinness’s Death and Adams’s Tribute
In the spring before Adams announced his retirement from the presidency of Sinn Féin, McGuinness died of a rare genetic disease. The loss came as Adams, nearing seventy, prepared to hand authority to Mary Lou McDonald, a leader whose professional adulthood belonged to the post-agreement period. The sequence placed the end of McGuinness’s life beside a generational transition within the party, but Adams’s retirement was also framed against the disappearance of a comrade who had shared both war and peace with him.
At McGuinness’s grave, Adams rejected the label of terrorist and called him a freedom fighter. The tribute condensed a lasting conflict over how their political generation would be remembered. For supporters, it affirmed a republican account of sacrifice and struggle; for critics, it could not by itself resolve the consequences of violence. Its setting mattered: the words were spoken at the grave of a dead comrade, not in a negotiation room, and they connected bereavement to the public contest over the meaning of the conflict.
Significance of the Partnership
Adams’s later public persona was increasingly that of an approachable political elder, while his history continued to carry what the book calls the whiff of cordite. The account credits him with helping bring the fighting to an end and building a successful political party, even as it describes the survival of his power and the unresolved suspicion surrounding his claims about his past. McGuinness’s earlier death sharpened the contrast between the movement’s wartime generation and the party’s post-agreement leadership, but their shared record remained central to Adams’s story.
The relationship therefore embodies both transformation and continuity. The former gunman became a deputy first minister; the longtime comrade became a central figure in a political party that entered government and negotiated with former opponents. Their partnership helped make that passage publicly legible, but it did not make the past consensual. Adams’s eulogy and McGuinness’s defence of him during the arrest reveal a bond expressed through political solidarity, while the disputes around the conflict remain part of what that solidarity means.