“The violent theft of time.”
Shrill: Notes from a Loud Woman“The violent theft of time” is Lindy West’s phrase for the material costs of online harassment: the hours spent responding to abuse, the disruption of paid work, and the wider physical and emotional consequences that follow. It rejects the idea that online attacks remain safely on a screen, showing instead how they enter professional routines, personal relationships, and ordinary decisions about safety.
Meaning and Immediate Context
The phrase appears as West recounts seeking help after an online extortion attempt derailed a day she had planned to write about her abortion. A flood of spam messages crowded her inbox, forcing her to sort through hundreds of unwanted emails for legitimate correspondence from her agent, editors, and family. At the same time, a message demanded that she delete an old tweet in exchange for stopping the spam. The targeted tweet was a screenshot documenting a rape threat, so the coercion sought not only to disrupt her work but to remove evidence of the harassment.
West describes the resulting costs concretely: lost time, potential income, and damage to her mental health. She contacted the Federal Bureau of Investigation, filled out help requests for several services, and tried to recover a usable inbox while continuing to work. The agency receptionist redirected her to the Washington State Patrol; nobody answered there, and West abandoned the attempt. The absence of recourse sharpened the phrase’s meaning: the attack consumed her time while the institutions she contacted offered no effective remedy.
From Online Abuse to Material Harm
West situates the incident within a harassment campaign that had occupied her life for years and, more broadly, contributed to women being driven off the Internet. She explicitly treats the abuse as physical in its consequences. It puts her on the phone with authorities, brings tension headaches and anxiety attacks, changes how she assesses strangers and her own safety, alienates friends, and takes time away from family. The stated purpose of such harassment is to traumatize her, erode her mental health, and force her to leave her job.
The phrase therefore describes more than the minutes consumed by any single attack. It gathers together cumulative losses that are individually easy to dismiss: interrupted work, vigilance in public, damaged relationships, and the energy required to keep functioning. West contrasts the impersonal comments she encountered early in her career at The Stranger with a later troll who made her feel unsafe by targeting her personally. That shift marks the movement from criticism of published work into intrusion on what she calls her real life.
Workplace Systems and Unpaid Moderation
At Jezebel, the costs of harassment were built into the job. Under Kinja, the platform introduced by Gawker Media publisher Nick Denton, commenters could create hosted blogs, while writers themselves moderated comments. West describes an editorial boundary being blurred: the work of paid, vetted journalists appeared alongside material produced by anonymous, unpaid commenters, some of whom used the platform to antagonize staff.
Keeping articles readable required writers to dismiss and ban abusive comments individually. At Jezebel, that meant handling a constant stream of violent and sexually abusive images; the work was emotionally gruesome but treated as part of the job. One user also registered a hostile handle that produced a permanent blog hosted by West’s employer and placed it alongside her professional work. The example makes the platform’s role tangible: the infrastructure that hosted her writing also legitimized and preserved material directed at her, while the burden of managing it fell to the target.
The Cost of Endurance
West does not present adaptation as a cure. She notes that a person may learn to tune out some of the chatter, stop searching for their name so often, and continue coping day by day. But she describes these defenses as partial coverings rather than resolution. Her capacity to withstand abuse is itself a loss: the armor required to keep working weighs heavily, and the apparent resilience comes with distance from the world and diminished ease in human connection.
In this context, “The violent theft of time” is both a description of labor and a criticism of the conditions that make targets perform it. West’s time is taken first by the harassment and then by the practical and emotional work of managing its consequences. The phrase resists treating that expenditure as a private inconvenience or a test of individual toughness; it identifies a sustained harm that obstructs work, relationships, and participation online.