Lindy and Aham restarting their romantic relationship
Shrill: Notes from a Loud WomanLindy West and Aham restart their romantic relationship after a breakup, but the reconciliation does not restore their former partnership. It grows out of a period of uncertainty, West’s grief for her father, and Aham’s willingness to care for her without treating that care as an obligation. Their eventual decision follows an exhausting two-day conversation and marks, in West’s account, the start of a new relationship between people changed by what has happened to them.
Limbo After the Breakup
West and Aham return to Los Angeles and spend several months in an unsettled arrangement. Aham goes on tour; West begins working at Jezebel. They are not a couple, yet they are happy in a way neither recognizes from their previous relationship. This in-between state matters: their closeness is present before either of them agrees to rebuild the partnership, and the narrative does not present reunion as an immediate decision or a simple resumption of what came before.
West describes the change as something she notices only in retrospect: Aham has become family even though they have sworn they are not getting back together. That distinction gives the reconciliation its particular shape. Affection and belonging have reappeared before the formal relationship does, while the two continue to live with the contradiction between their declared separation and their growing intimacy.
Grief and Care
The decisive change in their circumstances comes after West’s father dies. West explicitly rejects the idea that anyone should hope for a parent’s death to repair a troubled relationship; instead, she explains how grief altered the balance between herself and Aham. She was older, and her pain, followed later by her career, occupied space in her life that had previously been taken up by the relationship. West suggests that this shift gave Aham room to be present without being asked to serve as the center of her world.
During the month of emotional triage, Aham comes to West’s mother’s basement and mixes gin and tonics for her auntie Astri. West emphasizes that he did so because he wanted to help, not because he felt bound by duty; his unanticipated selflessness surprised them both. His joking remark, “I am a narcissist,” followed by the qualification that he did not want to “date my own reflection,” gives their changing dynamic a wry shorthand: the relationship could make room for care that was not simply a demand to be needed.
The period remains horrendous, but it is not without pleasure. West says they work hard to make each other laugh and become themselves again. She likens the experience to a reset. The word signals neither an erasure of grief nor a return to an earlier version of the couple. Rather, the difficult circumstances interrupt an established pattern and allow them to encounter each other differently.
The Decision to Begin Again
When Aham returns from tour, the two sit down for what West calls a two-day feelings marathon. Even for someone who describes herself as habitually emotional, the process is a nightmare. They schedule breaks and treat the conversation like labor, punching in and out like coal miners. They even write a contract about how much crying is allowed: West proposes “100 percent of the time,” while Aham’s low offer is a blank stare. The comic bookkeeping makes the emotional effort visible without diminishing its seriousness.
West withholds some details, saying they are either boring or hers alone. What she does disclose is the outcome: they become a couple again. She resists calling it simply getting back together, because the decision does not feel like convening the old relationship once more. It feels like making a new one. Aham’s condition makes the risk plain: “If we’re going to do this,” he tells her with his “most Intense Face,” “we’re really doing it. Don’t change your mind on me.” The relationship resumes with an explicit demand for commitment, not with an assumption that the previous bond can be restored unchanged.
A New Relationship, Not a Reprise
West frames the reconciliation against her skepticism about couples reuniting. Her mother, whom she casts as the realist, does not quite believe that getting back together is a real thing. West associates her childhood faith in reunion with a simpler conception of love: a relationship was something that happened to a person, rather than something people built. In that understanding, The Parent Trap could stand as the ultimate love story. Adult partnership, by contrast, requires work and decisions, and the two-day conversation supplies a concrete form for that work.
The playful labels West gives the earlier and later partnerships—“Relationship: The Phantom Menace” and “Relationship: Part Deux”—make the distinction comic, but also establish that time and change matter. The people entering the renewed relationship are not, in her telling, the same people who formed the first one. The reconciliation is therefore not proof that separation never happened; it is an account of how grief, changed priorities, care, humor, and deliberate conversation make another beginning possible. Its significance lies in West’s insistence that the relationship is rebuilt, not recovered.