“Lili Marlene”
Smilla's Sense of Snow“Lili Marlene” is the song that breaks into Benedicte Clahn’s account of her work in postwar Germany and visibly alters the act of remembering. When the pianist plays it at a march tempo, in the manner of Marlene Dietrich’s performance of one verse, Clahn closes her eyes and her voice changes; the melody makes the past present in a way her preceding description had not.
The Song Enters the Recollection
Clahn has been describing the work of Danish women assigned to read mail after the war. The account is specific and procedural: letters were opened, read, stamped “CENSORED,” and taped shut, while photographs and drawings were removed. The Allies were also seeking traces of the underground Nazi organization Edelweiss, and letters containing its name or clues to it were forwarded for further attention.
In the middle of this testimony, the pianist moves into “Lili Marlene.” The song is not introduced by Clahn as a deliberate illustration; it arrives from the room as she speaks. The narration marks the coincidence as almost telepathic, setting the music’s timing against her unfolding story.
A Change in the Act of Speaking
Before the song, Clahn’s account conveys both the routine of censorship and the material circumstances around it: the women lived in shared rooms, wore uniforms, and worked under military authority. The melody interrupts that explanatory mode. Clahn closes her eyes, recognizes the song, and says, “That song.” Her brief response replaces the extended description with a pause of recognition.
The narration has already observed that a speaker changes the moment she becomes absorbed in her story. The song makes that change perceptible: it is not merely part of the background music but a cue that alters Clahn’s voice and attention. The passage then waits for the song to end before the pianist slips into “Ich hab noch einen Koffer in Berlin,” extending the musical turn into another postwar song.
Narrative Significance
“Lili Marlene” functions as a hinge between public history and personal recollection. Clahn’s work involved sorting and controlling other people’s words; now a familiar melody interrupts her own ordered account and signals that memory is becoming more than a report of duties. The text does not specify which particular experience the song recalls, so its force lies in the visible change it produces rather than in an explained biographical association.
The scene also makes listening part of the narrative’s form. The pianist continues playing while Clahn’s attention withdraws from the room and turns toward the song; the narration registers this shift through her closed eyes, altered voice, and few spoken words. The melody briefly takes over the scene, allowing the remembered past to surface without supplying details the passage leaves unstated.