Roy’s Drinking, Sobriety, and Return
The Master Butchers Singing ClubRoy’s dependence on alcohol repeatedly damages his life and daughter, while brief sobriety offers an imperfect chance for change.
increasing
Bearing strength in each event
decreasing
A Father Lost in Grief

Drinking as Mourning
A loss becomes a habit
Roy Watzka turns to alcohol after losing Minnie. In time, drinking becomes less a response to grief than a force that organizes his life.
Delphine bears the cost
Delphine grows up cleaning, working, and protecting what little the household has. Her affection for Roy coexists with anger at his failures.
A House Neglected

The Ruin at Home
Delphine confronts the mess
Delphine finds Roy’s home full of rot and refuse. She and Cyprian remove the garbage while Roy is temporarily taken to town.
A deeper discovery
The filth hides a sealed cellar and the Chavers family’s bodies. Roy’s drinking has left him unable to explain what happened.
Sobriety After Eva

A Different Roy
Fear changes his habits
Haunted by the cellar deaths, Roy stops drinking for a time. He repairs his home and begins caring for Delphine in ways she has never expected.
Hope remains fragile
His sobriety allows Delphine to glimpse a capable father. She wants to believe the change can last, despite knowing his history.
Relapse and Delirium

The Old Pattern Returns
Denial breaks
Step-and-a-Half tells Delphine that Roy has started drinking again. Delphine recognizes signs she had overlooked and feels anger and helplessness return.
A public collapse
Roy wanders naked through town in delirium. Delphine chases and restrains him, then resumes the exhausting work of keeping him alive.
A Final Confession

Death and Truth
The past comes into speech
Weak and medicated, Roy admits that he sent Mr. Chavers to the cellar and may have closed the hatch. Delphine hears the painful limits of his memory.
No easy absolution
Roy dies after years of drinking and dependence. Delphine grieves the father she had and the sober father she briefly began to know.
After Minnie’s death
1934, when Delphine returns
After Eva’s death
After Delphine returns from Chicago
Near the end of Roy’s life