Lionel Bengelsdorf’s Collaboration
The Plot Against AmericaBengelsdorf’s effort to secure acceptance through cooperation with Lindbergh culminates in public influence and arrest.
increasing
Bearing strength in each event
decreasing
A Public Endorsement

A Public Endorsement
Loyalty as argument
Lionel Bengelsdorf endorses Charles A. Lindbergh, declaring that Jewish and national interests can align.
He portrays support as proof of Jewish devotion to America.
A disputed strategy
Many Jews see his endorsement as legitimizing an anti-Semitic candidate.
The Madison Square Garden Speech

The Madison Square Garden Speech
A defense of Lindbergh
Bengelsdorf tells a national audience that Lindbergh’s German visits served American military interests.
He argues that neutrality will protect both Jews and the country from war.
A painful reception
Herman and Alvin hear the speech as an effort to make anti-Semitism acceptable.
Advisor to the President

Advisor to the President
Institutional influence
Bengelsdorf becomes director of the Office of American Absorption and advises Lindbergh on Jewish affairs.
He claims that programs like Just Folks will lessen mistrust and widen participation.
A contested assurance
His confidence cannot resolve the coercive character of the government’s policies.
The White House Dinner

The White House Dinner
A public alliance
Bengelsdorf and Evelyn attend the state dinner honoring Joachim von Ribbentrop.
Their presence signals confidence in the administration’s diplomatic course.
Political exposure
The celebration increases opposition and makes the rabbi’s loyalties more visible.
Arrest and Discredit

Arrest and Discredit
Sudden reversal
During Wheeler’s crisis, the FBI arrests Bengelsdorf as a suspected conspirator.
Evelyn cannot find him and turns to the family she had alienated.
The failed bargain
His strategy of accommodation offers no protection once political power changes hands.
October 1940
October 1940
1941
April 1942
October 15, 1942