Hopewell, New Jersey
The Plot Against AmericaHopewell, New Jersey, is the rural setting of the Lindbergh family’s secluded home and the starting point of the 1932 kidnapping of Charles Lindbergh Jr. The episode makes the town more than a backdrop: it anchors a national tragedy that later becomes, in a contested account, the hidden origin of the Lindberghs’ political submission to Nazi power.
Setting and the kidnapping
In March 1932, Charles Lindbergh Jr. was taken from his family’s newly built home in rural Hopewell, a secluded property set on 435 acres. The child was carried from his second-story nursery by way of a makeshift ladder while his mother and nurse were occupied elsewhere in the house. The kidnapping turned the privacy of the family home into a site of national attention.
Some ten weeks later, a baby’s decomposing body was found by chance in nearby woods. The uncertainty surrounding the child’s fate and the discovery’s proximity to the house fixed Hopewell in the public story of the crime. The case ended with the conviction of Bruno Hauptmann, a German immigrant carpenter and former convict, after a six-week trial in Flemington, New Jersey. He was executed in April 1936.
A site recast by a later account
Much later, after Rabbi Bengelsdorf’s arrest, Aunt Evelyn passed on an account attributed to Anne Morrow Lindbergh. In the rabbi’s recapitulation, the Nazi Party had arranged the kidnapping shortly before Adolf Hitler came to power. According to this version, Bruno Hauptmann carried the infant from the Hopewell home, but Charles Lindbergh Jr. was smuggled to Germany; the body found in the woods was another child, deliberately substituted to conceal the abduction and secure Hauptmann’s conviction.
The account is presented as an alleged revelation, not as an independently confirmed explanation of the crime. Its implications nevertheless transform Hopewell’s place in the story: the home becomes the starting point of a secret hostage-taking, while the nearby woods become, in this version, part of a deception that reshaped the Lindberghs’ lives and the country’s political destiny.
Narrative significance
The novel first places Hopewell within the familiar public history of the kidnapping and the family’s attempt to protect their privacy. It later returns to the same event through a story relayed by several people, with Anne Morrow Lindbergh’s alleged confession reaching the Roth family through Rabbi Bengelsdorf and Aunt Evelyn. That shift in how the episode is told makes the location a hinge between apparent history and the novel’s alternate account of political influence.
Hopewell’s significance lies in this double framing. It is both the actual setting of the infant’s disappearance in the novel’s historical account and the origin point of a later theory that connects Lindbergh’s public admiration of Nazi Germany to coercion over his missing child. The place remains constant while the explanation of what began there changes.