Republicans supporting Lindbergh
The Plot Against AmericaRepublicans supporting Lindbergh are the political coalition that carries Charles A. Lindbergh into the presidency and sustains his isolationist program. The novel presents them not simply as a party organization but as an alliance of Republican politicians, anti-interventionists, and public supporters whose claims to patriotism and peace coexist with policies that place pressure on Jewish Americans and other dissenters. Its shifting composition and the consequences of its rule make the coalition central to the story’s account of democratic vulnerability.
Electoral Coalition and Isolationism
The coalition’s defining appeal is the promise to keep the United States out of foreign wars. Lindbergh presents that aim as a matter of national independence, while the peacetime draft instituted at his request requires eighteen-year-olds to undergo twenty-four months of military training and remain available in the reserves for eight years. The arrangement reveals a tension in the program: the administration invokes peace and national self-sufficiency while maintaining a large, long-term military obligation. To Herman Roth, the language of independence means turning away from former allies and drawing closer to their enemies; his response gives the political slogan a sharply different meaning within the family.
Burton K. Wheeler’s place on the ticket makes the coalition’s breadth—and its political calculation—especially visible. Once a Democratic supporter of Franklin D. Roosevelt and a figure associated with labor politics in Montana, Wheeler had moved through the Progressive Party before joining Lindbergh and the right-wing isolationists in America First. Lindbergh’s Republican allies selected him as running mate partly because his Montana political organization had helped elect Republicans, but chiefly because a Democrat on the ticket could advertise bipartisan support for isolationism. Wheeler also supplied a combative public voice unlike Lindbergh’s: he attacked Roosevelt and the Democrats, including after Roosevelt criticized the planned White House invitation to the German foreign minister. Wheeler predicted that the Democrats would suffer further congressional losses if they campaigned on what he described as war-minded arguments.
The coalition’s electoral strength is reinforced by a largely Republican press, which celebrates Lindbergh’s standing after his nationwide flying tour and disputes the Democratic criticism of the proposed state dinner. This public framing casts the controversy as a political misrepresentation rather than a warning about the administration’s direction. Lindbergh’s landslide victory in 1940 gives the coalition an unmistakable electoral mandate, but the novel repeatedly sets that popular support beside the vulnerability of those who oppose its policies.
Administration and Assimilation Policy
Under Lindbergh, the federal government gives institutional form to the coalition’s vision of national belonging. The Office of American Absorption describes its work as encouraging religious and national minorities to become more fully incorporated into society, but its conspicuous attention falls on Jewish Americans. Just Folks, one of its programs, sends Jewish boys aged twelve to eighteen from city neighborhoods to work for eight weeks as farm laborers far from home. Sandy Roth joins the program for a summer apprenticeship with a Kentucky tobacco farmer, supported by his aunt Evelyn, who works for Lionel Bengelsdorf, New Jersey’s director of the office. For the Roth family, Sandy’s departure is both a personal separation and a political dispute: his father objects to the implication that Jewish citizens require a special program to become American.
Homestead 42 extends the same pressure into adult and family life. In a letter dated May 22, 1942, Metropolitan Life informs Herman Roth that, at the Office of American Absorption’s request, the company is offering relocation opportunities to selected senior employees. Its letter invokes the Homestead Act of 1862 and presents government-funded moves as a chance for families to deepen their Americanness in regions previously inaccessible to them. The polished language of opportunity masks the program’s significance for its targets: Jewish families are being encouraged to leave established communities under a national policy administered through both government and corporate institutions. Together, Just Folks and Homestead 42 show how the coalition’s assimilationist agenda operates through organized programs and employment arrangements, not only through public rhetoric.
Public Opposition and Community Response
The coalition’s support for Lindbergh becomes more visible in the treatment of organized opposition. Walter Winchell, dismissed from his broadcasting and newspaper positions, takes his campaign to the streets, beginning in New York on Labor Day week. His appearance at Broadway and 42nd Street draws crowds that grow from hundreds to nearly ten thousand, and he carries his denunciation of fascism from New York into New England. At a campaign stop in South Boston, a hostile crowd gathers; an attempted attack interrupts his speech, and his bodyguards take him to hospital for treatment. The novel presents this episode as the moment when the danger Winchell has been describing emerges openly in public life.
After violence in Detroit, Jewish residents in Newark prepare for the possibility that unrest will spread to their own streets. Rabbi Joachim Prinz and five other prominent residents establish the Newark Committee of Concerned Jewish Citizens, which meets with city and state officials to plan for community safety. The committee seeks federal attention as well, but Bengelsdorf’s office characterizes the matter as local and directs them back to municipal and state authorities. Separately, Longy Zwillman assigns Bullet Apfelbaum to recruit local young men into the Provisional Jewish Police. These parallel responses—official meetings and neighborhood self-organization—show how fear of political violence narrows the space in which ordinary civic life can continue.
The reaction to Winchell’s campaign also exposes a limit within the coalition’s patriotic language. The narrator describes how the Bund, previously weakened by investigations and criminal charges, regains strength after government harassment of its members ceases under Lindbergh. It stages a near-capacity rally at Madison Square Garden, attended by about twenty-five thousand people, in support of the administration’s invitation to the German foreign minister and against the Democrats. The Bund’s public presentation of itself as patriotic and anti-Communist helps conceal its fascist affiliations. The novel distinguishes this organization from Republicans supporting Lindbergh while showing how the administration’s policies create room for groups whose activities had previously faced official pressure.
Emergency Rule and Constitutional Contest
The coalition’s governing crisis comes into sharp view after Lindbergh disappears. Acting President Wheeler announces that martial law applies throughout the continental United States and the territories and possessions. He tells Congress that the president has been kidnapped, while the administration seals the borders with Canada and Mexico, closes airports and seaports, and assigns the armed forces and National Guard, in cooperation with federal and local authorities, to maintain order. The account leaves the kidnapping’s circumstances unresolved while making the expansion of state power immediate and concrete.
On October 15, the FBI takes Bengelsdorf into custody on suspicion of involvement in an alleged conspiracy against the country. Other prominent political, civic, and labor figures are arrested, and federal troops enter New York to assist the National Guard in suppressing unrest. The arrests and restrictions fall amid efforts to protest the government’s conduct. The following morning, Anne Morrow Lindbergh escapes from Walter Reed Army Hospital with help from Lindbergh loyalists inside the Secret Service and broadcasts an appeal to the country. She calls for the National Guard to disband, the armed forces to return to their bases, detainees to be released with their rights restored, and government-sequestered media to resume normal operations under the First Amendment. She also asks Congress to replace the acting president through the succession process and decide whether to hold a special presidential election.
The sequence does not portray the Republicans supporting Lindbergh as a uniform body with a single response: loyalists inside the Secret Service assist Anne Morrow Lindbergh even as Wheeler’s government imposes martial law and arrests its opponents. That contrast sharpens the novel’s central distinction between popular mandate and constitutional conduct. The coalition rises through an election fought on isolationist promises, but its administration’s treatment of dissent, assimilation, and emergency powers repeatedly tests what citizenship and political freedom mean in practice.