Rizzo’s plot to frame Ingrid
The Shape of WaterPietro Rizzo’s plot to frame Ingrid is the political conversion of a private death into leverage. When Silvio Luparello dies during a tryst at The Capo Massaria house, Rizzo first appears to be the trusted fixer called in to contain a compromising situation. Instead, he recognizes that the woman’s abandoned necklace and clothes can be made to implicate Ingrid, the daughter-in-law of Luparello’s likely political successor. By engineering where the body is found and planting further evidence, he turns concealment into a public scandal—and the scandal into a means of controlling his rivals.
The death and Rizzo’s opportunity
The plot begins with a woman who, after Luparello dies during sex or immediately afterward, loses her composure and drops the necklace she is wearing without noticing. She eventually calls Rizzo, Luparello’s political confidant, for help. He tells her to leave the house and leave the key where he can find it, promising to take care of the death and keep the tryst secret. At this stage, the woman expects to disappear from the affair once she has left the scene.
Rizzo reaches The Capo Massaria house and hurriedly dresses Luparello’s body, intending to remove it and have it discovered somewhere less compromising. The necklace on the floor, and the woman’s clothes in a wardrobe, change his calculation. He recognizes that the evidence may let him put both political allies and opponents under pressure. Rather than simply hide the affair, he can shape what others believe it means—and who will be damaged by that belief.
Turning Ingrid into a suspect
The woman is Ingrid Sjostrom, whose connection to Dr Cardamone makes the discovery politically useful. Cardamone is presented as Luparello’s natural successor, but Rizzo expects him to want nothing to do with Rizzo himself. The necklace can associate Ingrid with the place and time of Luparello’s death; Rizzo’s larger design is to make it seem that she was the woman who accompanied Luparello to the Pasture. Her foreignness and reputation become tools in that insinuation: the intended story casts her as someone whose supposed appetite for an illicit thrill would make the accusation seem plausible.
Rizzo’s scheme also draws power from Ingrid’s actual vulnerability. She explains that, two years earlier, Dr Cardamone entered her room while she was in Rome with him and threatened her; she went along with him because she was afraid. Later, when they lived in the same palazzo, he came into her room again, and she continued to fear him. She asked her husband, Giacomo, to move away, but he refused. Cardamone went on kissing and touching her whenever he had the chance. Ingrid had therefore asked Luparello to let her use his house on occasion. Rizzo exploits this coercive history by trying to make Ingrid appear to be Luparello’s willing mistress, converting abuse and access into apparent evidence against her.
Planting evidence and controlling the account
Rizzo enlists two men to carry out the practical parts of the deception. One is Angelo Nicotra, known in their circle as Marilyn. While Rizzo’s men remove Luparello’s body, Rizzo takes the keys Luparello had with him and returns to Montelusa to obtain documents of particular interest to him. Marilyn stages the appearance of sex in a parked car at the Pasture, gets out, hides the necklace behind a bush near an abandoned factory, and throws Ingrid’s bag over the factory wall. The bag bears her initials and had been found by Rizzo in the house, giving him another object with which to reinforce the false connection.
The two pieces of evidence are designed to work independently. The necklace is the visible card: its discovery can place Ingrid at the Pasture at the time of Luparello’s death. The bag is held back as a second card in case the necklace is pocketed or otherwise goes unreported. Rizzo benefits when a sanitation worker finds the necklace and turns it in to Salvo Montalbano. He can offer an explanation for that discovery while the planted bag remains available to strengthen the accusation.
Montalbano finds the bag by comparing accounts of the woman’s movements: she had a bag when she got out of Luparello’s car, but no bag when another car picked her up along the provincial road. Rizzo’s men then return to the little house and put things in order. At first light, Rizzo calls Cardamone and begins using the situation. The arrangement is not merely a false trail toward Ingrid; it is a carefully staged chain of objects, locations, and partial disclosures through which Rizzo can manage what different people know.
Political purpose and exposure
Rizzo’s purpose is to control the consequences of Luparello’s death, not simply to conceal its circumstances. He expects Luparello’s party associates to compete for the political inheritance, so he wants the dead politician disgraced enough that his former allies cannot comfortably rally under his banner. Making Ingrid appear to have taken him to the Pasture would implicate Cardamone through his daughter-in-law and leave the successor vulnerable to Rizzo’s pressure. Rizzo’s effort succeeds politically: he gains Cardamone’s compliance and achieves his immediate objective.
But he misjudges the human cost of the deception. Ingrid is not the woman who brought Luparello to the Pasture as the staged story suggests; Rizzo has redirected suspicion toward her by exploiting the evidence and her relationship to Cardamone. His double betrayal also reaches Giorgio, whose attachment to Luparello and distress at the threatened disgrace of his uncle’s memory become decisive. After seeing the photographs and recognizing Rizzo’s betrayal of both him and Luparello, Giorgio kills Rizzo. The plot thus achieves its political effect while producing the violent consequence its architect failed to anticipate.
Narrative significance
The account of the scheme is assembled through Montalbano’s explanation of how the necklace, the bag, the body’s location, and the conflicting testimony fit together. That structure makes the objects more than clues: each is a calculated instrument in Rizzo’s attempt to govern the story told about Luparello’s death. The necklace is made public, the bag is kept in reserve, and the body is moved to a place that will discredit the dead man. What begins as an effort to protect a secret becomes an operation for manufacturing a more useful lie.
The framing also exposes how political power can weaponize sexual reputation. Rizzo’s design depends on presenting Ingrid’s presence and vulnerability as evidence of willing participation, while obscuring the coercion she describes. The false account threatens her and gives Rizzo leverage over Cardamone, but it cannot contain the grief and rage of Giorgio, whose response turns the political calculation back upon its author. Rizzo’s plot succeeds as manipulation and fails as control: the scandal advances his position, yet the violence generated by his betrayals ends his own life.


