Readify

Johnstown, Pennsylvania

The War of the Roses

Johnstown, Pennsylvania, is the point of reference for Ann’s working-class family background and her uneasy position in the affluent Rose household. The novel presents the place through a sharply contrasting domestic image: a cramped wood-frame home associated with poverty, family strain, and Christmas misery, set against the Roses’ display of comfort and abundance.

Setting and Family Background

Ann’s family lives in a tiny wood-frame house in Johnstown, which she imagines as a kind of prison. During a lavish meal with the Roses, the cassoulet and fine wine sharpen her private comparison between their splendor and her family’s shabby circumstances. Her recollection becomes a vivid mental picture of her mother on a worn, sprung couch in a torn housecoat, with her father drinking beer in a frayed room. These details make Johnstown legible not through a broad account of the town, but through the domestic conditions Ann associates with home.

Ann’s Relationship to Johnstown

Ann believes Oliver Rose may regard her as a country bumpkin from Johnstown, though she qualifies that thought by wondering whether he has ever taken her seriously enough to form such an opinion. The place therefore marks both her actual family origins and the social insecurity she feels around Oliver. Her view is filtered through her own self-consciousness; the text does not establish that Oliver shares her judgment.

Christmas and Social Contrast

Ann’s memories of Johnstown return in connection with Christmas, which she has little reason to anticipate at home. She expects her parents to get blind drunk on Christmas Eve, followed the next day by hangovers and sometimes violent irritability. By contrast, at the Roses’ house she helps prepare food for a Greek Embassy buffet and is pleased to find that both Oliver and Barbara have bought her presents, even though the couple do not plan to exchange gifts with each other. Johnstown thus functions as the bleak counterpoint to the Roses’ material comfort, while Ann’s willingness to help with their preparations reflects how little appeal her own family’s holiday offers.