Leaving One Marriage and Building Another

This flow follows Cheryl Strayed / Sugar from a young marriage she cannot make herself remain in through a painful divorce and the more candid, imperfect partnership she builds with Mr. Sugar.

increasingBearing stren­gth in each eventdecreasing

A Marriage at Nineteen

Love Before Readiness A Rash Beginning Cheryl Strayed / Sugar meets her first husband shortly after turning nineteen and marries him a month before her twentieth birthday. He is passionate, sensitive, handsome, and devoted; she loves him too, though not with the same unqualified certainty. Their life together includes books, music, politics, road trips, sex, and the ordinary intimacies of a young couple. From the outside, the marriage has many signs of affection and companionship. The Quiet Urge to Leave Almost from the beginning, a voice inside Cheryl Strayed / Sugar says go. She tries to silence it by naming everything she loves about her husband and everything she fears losing if she leaves. The conflict is not that her husband is simply cruel or that the marriage has no tenderness. It is that affection and friendship cannot make her desire to remain true, and she has not yet learned how to trust that distinction.

London and the Fear of Leaving

Love and Unreadiness A Life on the Edge In London, Cheryl Strayed / Sugar is broke, technically homeless, and unable to work legally. She becomes a coffee girl in an accounting firm while trying to make a life with the man she loves, still unsure whether she is ready to be committed to one person. She believes that leaving would devastate both of them and that she might never love anyone as deeply again. The fear is so intense that it feels like evidence she should stay, even as she knows she does not want the life she is living. The Bundle on Her Head An older woman who talks with her during work breaks has an enormous bundle of rags on her head, but Cheryl Strayed / Sugar fails to mention this obvious fact when telling her husband about their conversations. When he points it out, the two laugh, and then Cheryl Strayed / Sugar breaks down. The missed detail becomes an image of what she has not been able to admit to herself: she can see that the relationship is no longer right, but fear keeps her from naming it. The memory later helps her tell another woman that fear, not confusion, can be what holds someone in place.

A Dirty Separation

Avoiding the Clean Break A Choice Made Sideways Cheryl Strayed / Sugar remains in a marriage she wants to leave because she cannot bear to break her husband’s heart. Rather than make a direct and considered ending, she eventually has sexual relationships outside the marriage. Her actions make the separation more painful for both of them. What begins as an effort to avoid hurting her husband becomes a betrayal that forces the truth into the open in the least merciful way. The Divorce The year or so of separating is marked by grief and conflict. Cheryl Strayed / Sugar and her first husband struggle together through the end of a relationship that once held genuine love and friendship. Divorcing him is the most excruciating decision of her life, but she later recognizes it as the wisest one. Her first husband deserves a partner who is not secretly listening to an insistent inner command to go, and Cheryl Strayed / Sugar must stop betraying both of them by pretending she can stay.

A Betrayal in the New Love

The Perfect Couple Breaks News on the Telephone A woman from a city where Mr. Sugar works calls the home he shares with Cheryl Strayed / Sugar. The caller tells Cheryl Strayed / Sugar that she has slept with him during his recent visit, revealing an infidelity he had not disclosed. The news destroys the young couple’s sense of innocence and exclusivity. Cheryl Strayed / Sugar feels as if the love they built on their dueling couches has become a lie, and the ordinary tenderness of their shared life suddenly looks impossible to trust. The Duel When Mr. Sugar comes home, Cheryl Strayed / Sugar confronts him. She calls the relationship over, and he apologizes, explains, and asks for another chance; she is furious, devastated, and still able to recognize some truth in what he says about his patterns and his desire to change. The conversation does not erase the betrayal. It begins the harder work of understanding it, including the difference between a promise of perfection and a commitment to speak honestly and grow after failure.

A Chosen Partnership

Love Without Purity Staying and Changing Cheryl Strayed / Sugar chooses to remain with Mr. Sugar and work through the rupture. The decision later becomes one of the best of her life, not because the betrayal was harmless, but because it forces them into an ongoing conversation about sex, desire, commitment, and trust. The couple’s relationship remains imperfect. They encounter other struggles and find themselves in difficulty together, but Cheryl Strayed / Sugar no longer experiences the partnership as a fight for her freedom. A Different Measure of Success With time, she sees that both her first husband and Mr. Sugar are good men, yet only one relationship feels right at its core. The contrast teaches her that kindness alone does not oblige someone to stay and that pain alone does not make a relationship beyond repair. Her later understanding rejects the idea of a spotless couple. A lasting partnership is not proof that nothing went wrong; it is a life two people continue to choose, including the difficult work of facing what they have done to one another.

A month before Cheryl Strayed / Sugar turns twenty

When Cheryl Strayed / Sugar is twenty

During the final year of her first marriage

About a year after Cheryl Strayed / Sugar and Mr. Sugar move in together

The years after the affair and reconciliation