Discovery of Russell Pickett’s body
Turtles All the Way DownThe discovery of Russell Pickett’s body turns a long, unresolved disappearance into a reported death—and exposes the choice Davis Pickett and Noah Pickett made to bring their father’s fate to light. Aza Holmes first learns of the discovery from a breaking-news report, but the decisive revelation arrives in Davis’s text: he and Noah, not Aza or Daisy Ramirez, told police where to search. The event closes one uncertainty while opening another, as Aza confronts both the brothers’ sacrifice and her own fear that she helped bring it about.
Causes and Background
The news arrives a month after Christmas vacation, as Aza is eating breakfast with her mother. The television shows a reporter outside the gates of Pickett estate. The report does not claim a positive identification: authorities believe the body found in an offshoot of the Pogue’s Run tunnel is that of Russell Davis Pickett, Sr. Sources close to the investigation say he likely died of exposure within a few days of disappearing. The report also says police found the body after receiving an anonymous tip. Its cautious phrasing matters: the discovery is presented as a strong identification, not yet an official confirmation.
The tip has a history in Aza’s involvement with the disappearance. She had told Davis about “the jogger’s mouth,” a cryptic clue connected to the case. After the news breaks, she worries that this information may have forced the brothers toward a decision they would otherwise have avoided. She had already kept her father’s old phone hidden in Harold’s trunk alongside a tote bag containing money. On an earlier afternoon at Applebee’s, she retrieved the phone and charger from the trunk, turned on the device, and looked through the pictures her father had taken. That private act of remembering sits in sharp contrast to the public news of another father’s death: in both cases, absence is made present through what remains and what can still be learned.
The Discovery Becomes News
Aza texts Davis at once: “Just saw the news. I’m so sorry, Davis. I know I’ve said that to you a lot, but I am. I’m just so sorry.” When he does not reply immediately, she adds that neither she nor Daisy gave the police information. Her message is not merely an apology; it is an attempt to separate their earlier investigation from the anonymous tip now associated with the recovery.
Davis answers that he knows who supplied it: “I know. It was us. Noah and I decided together.” His message identifies the tipsters as the brothers and makes their action deliberate rather than accidental. Aza repeats the news to her mother, explaining that Davis and Noah were the ones who told police where to look. The report’s anonymous source becomes a personal disclosure, and the discovery is no longer only a matter of authorities locating a body. It is also the consequence of the brothers choosing to make their father’s whereabouts known.
The Cost of Telling the Truth
Aza’s mother immediately sees the inheritance at stake. She says, “Can you imagine, that whole estate is going to a lizard?” Because Russell Pickett has not been declared dead after the seven-year waiting period, Davis and Noah could, in Aza’s understanding, have retained the possibility of seven more years at the estate and access to its comforts. Instead, they decided to let the inheritance go to a tuatara. Their decision gives the tip a cost beyond the emotional difficulty of reporting their father’s location: it relinquishes the future attached to the estate.
Aza interprets that choice through guilt. She says that perhaps she should not have told Davis about the jogger’s mouth, then imagines that she forced the brothers to choose between abandoning their father and abandoning their lives. Her mother asks her to be kind to herself and counters the worst of that interpretation: knowing the truth mattered more to Davis than the house, and he would not be left on the streets. The exchange does not erase Aza’s responsibility for having shared the clue, but it distinguishes giving information from making the brothers’ decision for them. Their action belongs to Davis and Noah, even as Aza struggles to understand her part in the chain of events.
Aftermath and Significance
The discovery leaves Davis facing a difficult day while his father’s name returns to public view. Aza waits for a reply after the first texts, imagining him hearing his name on the news again; the account does not supply an immediate reconciliation or a response that resolves their relationship. Instead, the event marks a lasting change in what they can know about one another and about Russell: the brothers chose to tell the police where to look, and the inheritance could pass to the tuatara as a result.
In the months afterward, Aza says she keeps going and gets better without ever quite getting well. She and Daisy Ramirez establish a Mental Health Alliance and a Fan-Fiction Workshop, though the two friends are the only members of each, and they spend many evenings together. Aza continues to miss Davis, her father, and Harold, describing being alive as being in a state of missing. That later reflection gives the discovery its emotional frame. Finding Russell’s body ends the search for his location, but it does not end the absences left by death, separation, or the choices made in its wake.


