Matilda
Unorthodox: The Scandalous Rejection of My Hasidic RootsMatilda enters the memoir first as a book and then as a possibility: its neglected, precocious heroine gives the young narrator a way to imagine that the life she endures may not be the life to which she belongs. The book’s promise of hidden power and rescue sustains her imagination, but its happy ending also sets up a painful contrast with her own discovery that no rescuer is coming. When she identifies a different kind of power in her ability to act convincingly, Matilda remains the measure of a hope that has changed shape.
Identity and First Appearance
The book is introduced through an epigraph from Roald Dahl’s Matilda. Its heroine longs for parents who are good, loving, understanding, honorable, and intelligent, although they are none of these things; because she is small and young, her only power over her family is her brainpower. That opening makes Matilda more than a reading recommendation. It establishes a parallel between a child’s limited authority within her family and the possibility that intelligence might offer a route to agency.
The memoir’s narrator does not encounter that parallel as a detached literary idea. In the library, where the quiet and high ceiling seem to give her thoughts room to expand, she reads among books selected for children. She cannot borrow them because she has no library card, so the freedom she finds in reading is available only while she is there. She nevertheless believes that books might make everything else in her life bearable if she could have them all the time. Matilda belongs to this temporary refuge: a story she can enter, though she cannot take it home.
A Heroine Who Seems to Know Her Reader
The narrator says that books by Roald Dahl seem to understand children like her: unfortunate, precocious, and despised or neglected by families and peers. The resemblance makes reading feel personal, as though the stories had been written with her in mind. Matilda’s particular appeal lies in the prospect that a child who appears powerless may possess an ability that adults have failed to recognize.
That identification expands through other children’s stories. After reading James and the Giant Peach, the narrator dreams of rolling away inside a fruit from Bubby’s garden. She imagines the strange child being transported to a magical place where she truly belongs, then discovering that her old life was a mistake and that she was extraordinary all along. She also imagines falling into Wonderland or passing through a wardrobe into Narnia. These fantasies place Matilda within a larger literary pattern: transformation promises not merely escape from a bad situation, but proof that the child’s difference has meaning.
The Promise and Failure of Rescue
Matilda gives the narrator a story in which a turning point arrives when hope seems lost and the heroine discovers her power. Reading about that moment, the narrator wonders whether a power is dormant within her too. She imagines going home with Miss Honey, as Matilda does, and interprets the possibility of rescue as evidence that her own circumstances might eventually resolve into justice.
The expectation extends beyond this one book. Because she has not yet begun reading adult books, the narrator takes the happy endings of children’s literature as a rule of life: in the physics of imagination, a child can accept only a just world. She waits a long time for someone to arrive and save her, in the manner of the stories. The eventual recognition that no one will pick up the glass slipper she has left behind marks a break between literary promise and lived expectation. Matilda’s power still matters, but the rescue attached to it cannot be trusted as a prediction of what will happen to the reader.
From Imagined Power to Performance
The memoir later returns to Matilda when the narrator interprets her own conduct. She has been branded insolent for speaking back and correcting teachers’ grammatical mistakes and misquotations; against the ideal of the quiet, spiritually full woman, her instinct to comment makes her conspicuous. Matilda offers a contrasting model in which a child’s mind can be a source of power rather than a liability.
The narrator’s actual discovery is not telekinesis or a miraculous transformation. After she invents a mouse in the classroom, she sustains the deception so convincingly that her classmates believe her fear, while even the teacher interviews her about where the mouse might have gone. When Bubby and Zeidy laugh after hearing about the incident, Chaya alone looks at her suspiciously without challenging her. The narrator feels triumphant: she can pretend, act, and keep the truth hidden. This is the secret power she recognizes in herself, distinct from Matilda’s brainpower but prompted by the same question of how a child might gain agency in a world controlled by others.
Matilda therefore serves as both refuge and counterpoint. Its heroine gives the narrator language for feeling neglected and hope that apparent powerlessness may conceal something extraordinary. Yet the memoir does not simply reproduce the book’s happy resolution: the anticipated rescuer never arrives, and the narrator’s own power emerges through performance rather than magic. The story’s promise survives as an imaginative resource, even as experience forces its reader to revise what rescue and power can mean.
