Mind over matter
Unorthodox: The Scandalous Rejection of My Hasidic Roots“Mind over matter” is Jessica’s parting phrase to Deborah after biofeedback, a compact formula for the effort to manage anxiety through conscious control. Repeated with a tap to the forehead, it turns therapeutic instruction into a bodily gesture; the surrounding narrative tests its confidence against distress that does not simply disappear.
Biofeedback and the Promise of Control
In weekly sessions, Jessica teaches Deborah to recognize anxiety and respond to it through breathing, mental clearing, and muscle relaxation. Deborah watches the numbers on a screen go down as she practices. Jessica frames the work as a skill Deborah can learn, telling her, “Just remember, you are always in control. Your anxiety can never get the best of you unless you let it.” The phrase “Mind over matter” gives that assurance its shortest, most memorable form.
A Repeated Parting Formula
After Deborah’s last session, Jessica gives her the same parting words as usual: “Mind over matter,” she says, tapping her forehead. “Mind over matter.” The repetition makes the phrase sound like both a reminder and an exercise, linking thought to the physical act of regulating the body. Its return at the close of treatment marks the lesson Deborah is meant to carry beyond the therapist’s office.
The Limits of the Mantra
At home, Deborah keeps practicing the breathing exercises, particularly when Eli’s presence sets off waves of anxiety. She can hold the feeling at a distance, but it never goes away; she describes the effort as a fight against an enemy that seems certain to outlast her. At night, frightening hallucinations make even her bed and the room around her feel unsafe. Against this continuing distress, “Mind over matter” remains an instruction rather than a cure: the phrase names an effort to regain some control without suggesting that anxiety has been overcome.