New Orleans
Unorthodox: The Scandalous Rejection of My Hasidic RootsNew Orleans becomes the setting in which Devorah’s first solo journey turns into a decisive recognition of her independence. Far from the Hasidic world she left, she explores a city she wants to encounter beyond its tourist image; on her final morning there, a cup of chicory coffee on a balcony helps her understand what freedom has come to mean in her life.
Setting and First Independent Visit
The journey is a personal first: Devorah is traveling alone, visiting a city she understands to have no Hasidic residents and few kosher restaurants, and doing so without the Orthodox costume or the intention of restricting herself to permitted experiences. The cabdriver assumes she wants to party over the weekend. She explains that she wants to see the city itself, meet people who have lived there all their lives, and hear their stories. Her wish to look beyond the familiar tourist destinations marks the trip as more than sightseeing: she is testing what it means to choose her own experiences.
The epilogue returns to the city on her last day. At seven in the morning, after the celebrating crowds have left Chartres Street, Devorah sits on a wrought-iron balcony with oatmeal, berries, and café au lait. The silver pot and the coffee’s sweetness are part of a scene of unhurried self-direction: she has chosen the familiar breakfast after two days of crawfish in butter sauce, and she can look out over a city waking after its revelry.
Encounters and the City Beyond Tourism
During the trip, a man with pale blue eyes and a cross offers to buy Devorah a drink. She declines alcohol, explaining that she wants to remember everything; he says he does not drink either, though she is unsure whether to believe him. He shows her a house he restored himself after Katrina and his shotgun collection. When he drops her at her hotel at four in the morning, she lets him kiss her. The episode records a choice made on her own terms, without turning the encounter into a settled romance or claiming more about it than the account supplies.
The conversation with the cabdriver and this late-night encounter frame the trip as an effort to meet people rather than simply pass through a destination. Devorah wants the stories of lifelong residents, and the man’s account of restoring his house gives her a glimpse of a life shaped by the city’s recent past. Her refusal of a drink is not presented as fear of alcohol; she wants to remain attentive enough to remember what she experiences.
Familiarity, Difference, and History
New Orleans surprises Devorah with points of contact as well as contrasts. The chicory in her café au lait recalls the coffee served in pitchers at her childhood school and summer camp. She realizes that the coffee had been mixed with chicory there too, and takes pleasure in discovering this small likeness between the city and the Hasidic world she came from.
Other comparisons are less comforting. The thick, invisible barriers between races remind her of Brooklyn, where people seemed to know their assigned places and those places did not mix. The city’s social intimacy, by contrast, recalls Williamsburg, where people also seem to know one another. Devorah sees New Orleans as a place suffering from post-traumatic stress and living in its history; that perspective leads her to regard Williamsburg as a recreation of a deceased ideal. The comparison unsettles the idea that her former community was wholly unique: both places, in different ways, appear shaped by a past they continue to inhabit.
The City as an Epiphany of Freedom
On the balcony, with street cleaners hosing down the debris left by the previous night’s celebrations, Devorah recognizes that the trip has given her the freedom she once imagined from afar. She has gone somewhere without anyone holding her back or telling her where she cannot go. The city matters not because it resolves every difficulty, but because it makes travel and self-determination concrete: she can leave, choose a destination, and anticipate further journeys.
That certainty arrives a year after her break with her former life, a difficult period of adjustment in which she felt conspicuous and wished to disappear into a crowd. New Orleans supplies a counter-image. Its remembered coffee, street scene, and freely chosen encounters accompany her understanding that she no longer has to yearn for the impossible. The city’s decisive significance is therefore both geographical and inward: it is the place where a first independent trip confirms that the freedom she sought can become an ordinary, repeatable part of the life ahead.
