Readify

Niddah

Unorthodox: The Scandalous Rejection of My Hasidic Roots

Niddah is the menstrual-impurity status that Devorah encounters in marriage classes before her wedding, where it is presented as a cycle of separation followed by ritual purification. The rules shape her first experience of married life: they determine when she may be physically close to Eli, subject her body to inspection, and leave her feeling that religious purity has made her both a wife and an object of regulation. Their repetition becomes a source of estrangement rather than the renewal her teacher promises.

Definition and Rules

Devorah’s marriage teacher explains that Niddah is the term for a woman’s menstrual period and says its literal sense is being set aside, while reassuring her that it is simply the customary term. The explanation does not reassure Devorah. She finds the association with impurity humiliating and rejects the idea that menstruation makes her dirty. Her questions expose a divide between the teacher’s confident account of religious law and Devorah’s growing awareness of how the law assigns meaning to women’s bodies.

The status begins, as Devorah is taught, when a drop of menstrual blood appears. During Niddah, a husband must not touch his wife, even to pass her a plate; he must not see any part of her body or hear her sing. The rules therefore regulate ordinary contact as well as sexual intimacy. The teacher also describes women as having unpredictable cycles and urges prompt self-inspection when a period may be beginning. She invokes the historical exclusion of menstruating women from the Temple, explaining it as protection against the possibility of menstruation defiling the sacred place.

After menstruation ends, the woman counts seven consecutive clean days. Devorah learns that this requires twice-daily checks with cotton cloths for any sign of blood. Completion of the count is followed by immersion in a mikvah, after which the woman is considered pure again. The system divides the month into periods of restriction and permitted closeness, with bodily status determining the terms of a married couple’s contact.

Learning the Ritual Before Marriage

The lessons arrive while Devorah still imagines marriage as a straightforward way to make a home and become a good wife. Instead, she finds herself sorting the women she sees on the street into those who know these laws and those who do not. Seeing married women pushing double strollers in Williamsburg, she wonders how they accept a system that describes women as impure. Her reaction is not simply confusion about unfamiliar customs: she feels betrayed by the women in her life for not having prepared her for the rules.

The teacher presents the cycle as beneficial to marriage. In her account, a predictable alternation of denial and reunion renews the bond and prevents it from becoming boring; she also explains that men want what they cannot have. Devorah is uncomfortable with the implication that she is made available and unavailable for a man’s enjoyment. The promised marital benefit thus sharpens, rather than resolves, her concern that the rules define women chiefly through their usefulness to husbands.

Devorah is scheduled to immerse for the first time as a bride, five days before the wedding. She already has a birth-control prescription intended to regulate her cycle and avoid menstruation before the ceremony. Her teacher warns that if Devorah is still impure, the newlyweds cannot hold hands after the wedding or share an apartment, and a guardian would have to remain with her until purification. Devorah is also warned that the situation would become known locally and bring lasting embarrassment. The possibility of a disrupted wedding makes the ritual a matter of public reputation as well as religious observance.

The First Immersion

The mikvah is a discreet yellow-brick building on an unusually shaped block in Williamsburg. Devorah and Chaya enter through a side alley, ring a bell, and wait for a camera and buzzer to admit them through a heavy door. A receptionist recognizes Devorah as a bride and arranges for an attendant. Although her teacher had assured her that she could preserve her modesty during the inspection, the attendant’s scrutiny leaves Devorah feeling exposed and powerless. The ritual’s promise of purification is accompanied by the demand that another woman certify her status.

In the mikvah’s small pool, the attendant examines Devorah before leading her through the immersion. Devorah completes three immersions, taking care to follow the prescribed procedure and receive the attendant’s confirmation. The actions are religiously ordered and witnessed, but the experience is emotionally difficult: she works to conceal her distress and leaves the ritual in tears. For Devorah, the first immersion does not feel like a simple passage into married life. It makes the conflict between bodily privacy and religious supervision immediate.

Marriage, Repetition, and Consequences

The rules become more consequential when Devorah and Eli try to consummate their marriage. After a week of unsuccessful attempts, the rabbis tell them to stop because Devorah is bleeding and its cause cannot be determined with certainty. They classify her as Niddah, requiring her to begin the seven clean days and prepare for immersion before they can try again. An uncertain bodily symptom therefore places the couple back under the same schedule of separation and purification Devorah had only recently learned.

Later, the cycle marks their relationship in alternating stretches: periods when they cautiously approach one another and periods when they avoid contact to comply with Niddah. Devorah describes the repeated change in terms of being wanted and then set aside. By the time she adjusts to the intimacy permitted in one phase, the next period of separation returns. Eli follows the religious law closely; Devorah experiences his shifts in availability as rejection and cannot easily separate his observance from his feelings for her. Over time, she becomes reluctant to reach for him, fearing the next withdrawal, and describes herself as growing emotionally cold and detached from her own body.

Narrative Significance

Niddah marks a turning point in Devorah’s understanding of what marriage will require. Before her lessons, she has been sheltered from sexual knowledge and thinks of herself primarily as a spiritual being. Learning the rules forces her to confront her body as the object of constant attention and regulation. The discovery is not only new information about religious practice; it divides her sense of herself into a former, uninformed girl and a woman whose body is now subject to marital and ritual duties.

The narrative connects that change to the later damage in her marriage: Devorah understands her bodily resistance to the rules and expectations surrounding sex as an early source of the unhappiness that will help tear the marriage apart. Niddah’s repeated pattern of separation and return is intended, in the teacher’s explanation, to renew the marital bond. In Devorah’s experience, however, it makes closeness feel conditional and turns purification into a recurring reminder that religious law, rather than mutual feeling, sets the terms of intimacy.