Readify

Shabbat observance

Unorthodox: The Scandalous Rejection of My Hasidic Roots

Shabbat observance is presented as both a binding religious boundary and a rhythm that organizes work, worship, and family life. Its weekly cessation is especially visible in the pause imposed on Jewish businesses; its ending is marked by havdalah and by the deliberate return to ordinary activity. Through the narrator’s memories of her father restarting a bakery, household ceremonies, and the gendered practice of prayer, the observance appears not as an abstract rule but as a structure lived through labor, sound, food, and unequal access to religious life.

The Weekly Boundary

The account states that Jewish businesses must cease operating for the duration of Shabbos. At Beigel’s kosher bakery, work does not simply resume when the non-Jewish laborers are ready: a Jewish person must set things in motion again. The rule therefore gives the narrator’s father a particular role after Shabbos. One of his jobs is to turn on the ovens, a task whose requirements are simple but whose timing is religiously defined.

The rule also governs the pause before that work can begin. When the father brings the narrator to the bakery, the workers are already preparing dough, shaping it into rolls and loaves, but the machinery waits. As he flips the switches through the warehouse, the machines start humming and the production line gathers force. The narrator feels important because her father is important in this moment: the workers wait for his arrival before business can proceed as usual. The scene makes the observance’s boundary visible in the contrast between preparation and activation, and in the authority conferred on the person permitted to cross it.

Havdalah and the Return to Ordinary Time

The end of Shabbos is marked by havdalah. During the period of sefirah, after the Passover dishes have been put away, Zeidy remains at the table after the ceremony. He smells the smoking embers of the braided yellow candle and dips them into spilled wine, making them hiss. Around him, household work resumes: a dishwasher quivers with steam, and the narrator vacuums the carpet. The ceremony’s small, deliberate gestures share the room with the noise of chores, setting ritual transition against the practical demands of the household.

The timing of that transition changes with the season. In June, when Shabbos lasts longest, Zeidy does not say the havdalah blessing until 10:30 on Saturday night. At 11, relatives arrive from Borough Park for Melaveh Malkah, the meal after Shabbos. The narrator, who has spent the afternoon resting because of abdominal pain, joins the family for scrambled eggs and vegetable salad. Moshe has gone to a kosher pizza store on Marcy Avenue, where the Saturday-night line usually reaches into the street. The late meal and the errand show ordinary social and commercial life gathering momentum only after the sacred interval has ended.

Work, Food, and Family

The bakery visit connects the religious rule to the narrator’s childhood experience of belonging. As her father moves through the factory, the workers nod to him and pat her head with powdery gloves. The machinery begins to run, the floor vibrates, and trays of rolls pass into the ovens and emerge golden. Her father talks with the workers and eats an egg kichel while the bakery returns to production. The child’s sense of importance rests on seeing him as the person whose arrival makes this work possible.

The visit also becomes a route from the bakery back to family. The father selects boxes of baked goods on the way out, including cupcakes, babka, seven-layer cake, and black-and-white cookies. The food is delivered to the narrator’s grandparents’ house and spread across the dining-room table; Bubby particularly loves egg kichel. The observance thus has a material aftermath: once the bakery is restarted, its products become a shared family bounty. The rule’s interruption of work and the abundance that follows are held together in the narrator’s memory.

Religious Practice and Gender

The book places Shabbat observance within a wider pattern of religious practice that is not experienced equally by girls and boys. After Simchas Torah, the narrator describes returning to school and being told that girls do not go to shul. They pray at home or at school, while men’s prayers alone are described as regimented and counted. In class, the girls recite morning prayers from their siddurim. The narrator cannot read or speak Hebrew quickly enough to keep pace with the class’s chant, so she moves her lips and makes occasional sounds to appear to be praying.

The loss of melody sharpens the distinction between outward participation and inward feeling. When the girls were younger, tunes helped them remember the prayers; after age twelve, singing is forbidden to them. The narrator continues the motions under an overseer’s watch, but says the absence of melody has drained the joy from prayer. This passage does not define a Sabbath-specific rule; instead, it shows how the community’s broader organization of religious life shapes the narrator’s experience of observance, including who gathers in the synagogue and who is permitted to sing.

Calendar and Meaning

The account distinguishes Shabbos from Chol Hamoed, the four less ceremonial days in the middle of Sukkot. On those days, there are no laws about driving or spending money, but work is still prohibited, and families commonly take trips. The distinction shows that the calendar contains different kinds of restriction: the narrator’s cousins travel during Chol Hamoed, while the weekly Shabbos is associated with a business shutdown and a marked transition at its end.

Across these scenes, observance is conveyed through specific acts rather than through a formal exposition of religious law: a Jewish worker switches on ovens, Zeidy performs havdalah, family members gather for a late meal, and girls imitate the pace of prayers they cannot comfortably follow. The rule organizes time, work, and communal life, but the narrator’s memories also register its uneven effects. It gives her father a visible role in restarting the bakery, joins food to family affection, and stands beside forms of worship in which girls have less public presence and fewer permitted expressions.