Readify

The Rejection of Assassination

Watchmen

This flow traces the moral argument against revenge killing from Hector’s refusal through Odal’s survival and Kanus’s lawful removal.

increasingupBearing stren­gth in each eventdowndecreasing
The Revenge DemandThe Revenge Demand from "Watchmen". The Revenge Demand Geri’s Grief Geri Dulaq asks Hector H. Hector to kill Major Par Odal for murdering her father.
The Revenge Demand Geri’s Grief Geri Dulaq asks Hector H. Hector to kill Major Par Odal for murdering her father. Her demand is emotionally comprehensible because legal institutions appear unable to punish the architect of the crime. Hector feels the pressure of love, duty, and fear. He could become a hero by committing the act she wants. The Refusal He rejects revenge because Odal’s death would make him another deliberate killer. His decision costs him intimacy before it restores their relationship.
Mercy Under the GunMercy Under the Gun from "Watchmen". Mercy Under the Gun The Open Opportunity Hector obtains a gun while Odal is vulnerable and could kill him without a duel.
Mercy Under the Gun The Open Opportunity Hector obtains a gun while Odal is vulnerable and could kill him without a duel. Geri urges him to act immediately before guards arrive. Hector lowers the weapon and orders Odal to stand. He chooses restraint even while knowing that Odal may remain dangerous. Moral Independence The decision proves that Hector’s earlier refusal was not hesitation. He will not allow another person’s grief to determine his ethics.
Lawful DepositionLawful Deposition from "Watchmen". Lawful Deposition The Dictator Captured Romis prevents his followers from shooting Chancellor Kanus because an execution could create a civil war and a martyr.
Lawful Deposition The Dictator Captured Romis prevents his followers from shooting Chancellor Kanus because an execution could create a civil war and a martyr. The conspirators instead demand surrender. Kanus is placed in psychonic treatment rather than killed. The response rejects the logic that every political threat must be eliminated physically. A Difficult Justice The settlement is not sentimental forgiveness. It is an attempt to replace personal vengeance with institutions capable of containing a dangerous man.
after the first Hector–Odal confrontation
during the tri-di studio confrontation
during the Kerak Coup against Kanus