The Klooga Massacre and Moral Choice

Los pacientes del doctor García

This flow examines the divergent choices of Adrián Gallardo Ortega and Heinrich Beyer during the massacre and the different moral aftermaths they face.

increasing

Bearing strength in each event

decreasing

Volunteers at the Camp Volunteers at the Camp from "Los pacientes del doctor García". Orders in the Clearing A forced assembly Adrián and Jan are brought with other SS volunteers to a clearing near Klooga, where Jewish prisoners wait under…

Volunteers at the Camp from "Los pacientes del doctor García". Orders in the Clearing A forced assembly Adrián and Jan are brought with other SS volunteers to a clearing near Klooga, where Jewish prisoners wait under…

Orders in the Clearing A forced assembly Adrián and Jan are brought with other SS volunteers to a clearing near Klooga, where Jewish prisoners wait under guard. The order is plain Kleiber announces that the soldiers will help kill the prisoners, stripping the action of any moral disguise.

Beyer Refuses Beyer Refuses from "Los pacientes del doctor García". Conscience Against Command An explicit refusal Heinrich Beyer will not fire on the women and tells Kleiber that his conscience prevents obedience.

Beyer Refuses from "Los pacientes del doctor García". Conscience Against Command An explicit refusal Heinrich Beyer will not fire on the women and tells Kleiber that his conscience prevents obedience.

Conscience Against Command An explicit refusal Heinrich Beyer will not fire on the women and tells Kleiber that his conscience prevents obedience. Execution as warning Kleiber shoots him in front of the unit, making refusal’s cost unmistakable.

Gallardo Opens Fire Gallardo Opens Fire from "Los pacientes del doctor García". Participation in the Killing Witnessing the victims Adrián sees the starving prisoners as human beings and recognizes their fear and prayer.

Gallardo Opens Fire from "Los pacientes del doctor García". Participation in the Killing Witnessing the victims Adrián sees the starving prisoners as human beings and recognizes their fear and prayer.

Participation in the Killing Witnessing the victims Adrián sees the starving prisoners as human beings and recognizes their fear and prayer. A choice avoided He nevertheless joins the firing squad, choosing survival and obedience over the possibility of death.

Blaming the Victims Blaming the Victims from "Los pacientes del doctor García". A Defense Against Guilt The mind rewrites events Adrián decides that the prisoners’ composure was an accusation designed to make him a murderer.

Blaming the Victims from "Los pacientes del doctor García". A Defense Against Guilt The mind rewrites events Adrián decides that the prisoners’ composure was an accusation designed to make him a murderer.

A Defense Against Guilt The mind rewrites events Adrián decides that the prisoners’ composure was an accusation designed to make him a murderer. Hatred replaces remorse By transferring blame to victims, he numbs himself and becomes more like Jan’s ideology.

A Life Without Peace A Life Without Peace from "Los pacientes del doctor García". The Cost of Survival Retreat toward Berlin Adrián fights onward, detached from his former faith and family, and expects to die in the final defense.

A Life Without Peace from "Los pacientes del doctor García". The Cost of Survival Retreat toward Berlin Adrián fights onward, detached from his former faith and family, and expects to die in the final defense.

The Cost of Survival Retreat toward Berlin Adrián fights onward, detached from his former faith and family, and expects to die in the final defense. Crimes remain unresolved He escapes immediate justice by assuming another man’s identity, but his survival does not undo his participation.

20 September 1944

After the massacre

1944–1947