The Alliance of Convenience

Traces the uneasy political bond between Washington and governments whose repression becomes more acceptable when they cooperate against a shared enemy.

increasingBearing stren­gth in each eventdecreasing

A Shared Enemy

A Shared Enemy Governments targeted by militant groups offer to cooperate with the United States after the attacks. Common Interest Their leaders face real security threats and seek help against armed movements. A Larger Bargain Chomsky asks whether cooperation will respect law or permit new state abuses.

The Repressive Partners

The Repressive Partners The emerging coalition includes governments with records of violence against their own populations. Reciprocal Advantage They can gain American support for domestic campaigns by adopting the language of counterterrorism. Moral Compromise The partnership risks turning shared security interests into a shield against scrutiny.

Russian Cooperation

Russian Cooperation Russia’s partnership in the campaign could strengthen its position in Chechnya. Shared Security Language Actions against opponents can be presented as part of a common antiterrorist struggle. Concern for Civilians Chomsky warns that international backing may encourage violence rather than constrain it.

Turkey’s Gratitude

Turkey’s Gratitude Turkey offers support to the campaign and describes its relationship with Washington as one of special debt. Chomsky’s Counterpoint He recalls American support for Turkish military operations against Kurds and the extensive displacement they caused. A Complicated Bond The alliance joins strategic cooperation with a history of grave civilian harm.

Trust Without Accountability

Trust Without Accountability The alliance depends on cooperation among states whose interests and records differ sharply. Selective Standards Washington’s willingness to partner with some governments while excluding others reveals political criteria beneath moral claims. A Fragile Bond Without accountability, cooperation can deepen grievances and undermine the legitimacy it seeks to create.

September 2001

As the coalition forms in autumn 2001

September and October 2001

October 2001

As the coalition expands