Readify
Download App

The Citizen and the Condemned

The Social Contract

This flow traces Rousseau’s argument that public security may require severe powers, while the State’s authority must remain tied to common preservation and justice.

increasingupBearing stren­gth in each eventdowndecreasing
Life at Risk for the StateLife at Risk for the State from "The Social Contract". Life at Risk for the State Mutual Preservation Rousseau argues that those who accept the social pact accept some risks needed to preserve it.
Life at Risk for the State Mutual Preservation Rousseau argues that those who accept the social pact accept some risks needed to preserve it. A citizen may be called to defend the community. Conditional Obligation The claim rests on reciprocal protection, not a ruler’s private ownership of life. Public authority must be justified by the security the State provides.
Capital Punishment DefendedCapital Punishment Defended from "The Social Contract". Capital Punishment Defended A Security Argument Rousseau presents the death penalty as a consequence of a mutual compact against grave threats.
Capital Punishment Defended A Security Argument Rousseau presents the death penalty as a consequence of a mutual compact against grave threats. The citizen accepts a penalty in order to secure life under law. A Severe Classification He describes a convicted criminal as having placed himself outside the compact. This reasoning gives the State formidable power over those it identifies as enemies.
Particular Judgment SeparatedParticular Judgment Separated from "The Social Contract". Particular Judgment Separated Not an Act of Sovereignty Rousseau concedes that sentencing concerns a particular person, so it is not a general sovereign act.
Particular Judgment Separated Not an Act of Sovereignty Rousseau concedes that sentencing concerns a particular person, so it is not a general sovereign act. The Sovereign may confer the judicial function without exercising it directly. A Constitutional Limit The distinction preserves his definition of law as general while leaving practical punishment to institutions. It also reveals the danger of translating abstract principles into individual cases.
Execution RestrictedExecution Restricted from "The Social Contract". Execution Restricted Necessity, Not Example Rousseau says the State has no right to kill someone it can safely leave alive.
Execution Restricted Necessity, Not Example Rousseau says the State has no right to kill someone it can safely leave alive. Frequent punishment signals governmental weakness or negligence rather than strength. Prevention Preferred Punishment should not become a routine demonstration of authority. The State’s first task is preserving its members and preventing the conditions that produce crime.
The Innocent Must Not Be SacrificedThe Innocent Must Not Be Sacrificed from "The Social Contract". The Innocent Must Not Be Sacrificed The Smallest Member Counts The public compact obliges the community to protect each member, not only the majority.
The Innocent Must Not Be Sacrificed The Smallest Member Counts The public compact obliges the community to protect each member, not only the majority. A public benefit cannot by itself justify deliberately sacrificing an innocent person. Legitimacy Tested Rousseau calls such sacrifice a contradiction of the agreement that makes society legitimate. Collective preservation cannot be separated from the security owed to individuals.
Book II, Chapter V, on civic defense
Book II, Chapter V, during the discussion of criminal judgment
Book II, Chapter V, after the argument for punishment
Book II, Chapter V, at the warning against frequent punishment
Discourse on Political Economy, in the account of individual security