Readify
Download App

A Suitable People for Legislation

The Social Contract

This flow traces Rousseau’s account of the conditions under which a people might receive laws, and why reform imposed at the wrong moment can fail.

increasingupBearing stren­gth in each eventdowndecreasing
The People Must Be FittedThe People Must Be Fitted from "The Social Contract". The People Must Be Fitted Institutions Need a Ground A legislator must examine a people before designing its laws, much as an architect tests a site before…
The People Must Be Fitted Institutions Need a Ground A legislator must examine a people before designing its laws, much as an architect tests a site before construction. Good rules cannot work independently of social conditions. Fit Before Abstraction Legislation must consider a community’s capacity to receive it. A theoretically admirable system may fail when imposed on people unprepared to sustain it.
Custom Resists ReformCustom Resists Reform from "The Social Contract". Custom Resists Reform A Narrow Opening Rousseau says peoples are most teachable in youth; established customs and deep prejudices make later reform dangerous…
Custom Resists Reform A Narrow Opening Rousseau says peoples are most teachable in youth; established customs and deep prejudices make later reform dangerous and often futile. Institutional Inertia The obstacle is not only defective law but the habits that law has come to inhabit. Political renewal must reckon with a people’s accumulated history.
Revolutions Renew Some StatesRevolutions Renew Some States from "The Social Contract". Revolutions Renew Some States A Return of Vigor Periods of violence can sometimes make a people feel the horror of its past and regain political energy.
Revolutions Renew Some States A Return of Vigor Periods of violence can sometimes make a people feel the horror of its past and regain political energy. Rousseau cites Sparta, Rome, Holland, and Switzerland as cases of renewal. Rare and Irreversible Such opportunities are exceptional and cannot be summoned at will. A people that has lost its civic force may be destroyed by unrest rather than restored by it.
Premature Civilization CriticizedPremature Civilization Criticized from "The Social Contract". Premature Civilization Criticized Reform Out of Season Rousseau argues that Peter the Great tried to civilize Russia before it was ready, copying other nations…
Premature Civilization Criticized Reform Out of Season Rousseau argues that Peter the Great tried to civilize Russia before it was ready, copying other nations instead of developing its own character. A Prediction of Instability The example warns that borrowed institutions can displace a people’s possible development. For Rousseau, timing and local maturity matter as much as a reform’s stated aim.
Corsica as PossibilityCorsica as Possibility from "The Social Contract". Corsica as Possibility A People Recovering Liberty Rousseau presents Corsica as a community that has regained and defended its freedom, and therefore might…
Corsica as Possibility A People Recovering Liberty Rousseau presents Corsica as a community that has regained and defended its freedom, and therefore might still receive wise laws. A Deliberate Hope The prediction that the island may astonish Europe is part of his appeal for timely institution-building. It contrasts a living political opportunity with the inertia of established states.
Book II, Chapter VIII, at the opening comparison with a building site
Book II, Chapter VIII, when customs have hardened
Book II, Chapter VIII, during rare moments of political crisis
Book II, Chapter VIII, in Rousseau’s example of Russia
Book II, Chapter X, near the conclusion on legislation