The Role of Secrecy and Honesty

The negative consequences of secrecy and the value of honesty in relationships.

increasingBearing stren­gth in each eventdecreasing

Frank and Jane's Secret

Frank and Jane's Secret A Burden Shared Frank and Jane's secret engagement causes them both great stress. They must lie and deceive those around them. The Cost of Secrecy Jane's health suffers, and Frank's behavior becomes questionable. The secrecy nearly destroys their relationship.

Emma's Deception of Harriet

Emma's Deception of Harriet Unintentional Lies Emma misleads Harriet about Mr. Elton's feelings, causing Harriet to build false hopes. Emma is not honest with herself either. The Consequences Harriet is heartbroken when the truth comes out. Emma's lack of honesty damages their friendship temporarily.

Mr. Knightley's Openness

Mr. Knightley's Openness A Man of Truth Mr. Knightley always speaks honestly, even when it is painful. He values truth above politeness. Emma's Respect Emma respects Mr. Knightley for his honesty. His openness helps her grow and see her own faults.

Frank's Confession

Frank's Confession A Necessary Step Frank finally admits his engagement to his father and stepmother. This honesty is the first step toward reconciliation. Relief for All Once the truth is out, everyone can move forward. Jane is freed from her burden, and Frank is forgiven.

Emma's Honesty with Herself

Emma's Honesty with Herself A Personal Revelation Emma finally admits to herself that she loves Mr. Knightley. This self-honesty is crucial for her growth. Openness with Others Emma learns to be more honest with those she loves. She and Mr. Knightley build their relationship on truth.

throughout the story

when she encourages Harriet's false hopes

throughout, as he always speaks his mind

when he reveals the truth to the Westons

when she acknowledges her love for Mr. Knightley