Discovery of Bodies by Police

After the storm subsides, a rescue party from the mainland reaches Indian Island. They find ten dead bodies, each corresponding to the nursery rhyme. The police are baffled by the mystery, as there is no sign of an outsider. The investigation reveals that the victims were all guilty of crimes that the law could not punish. The police find diaries and notes left by the victims, but the puzzle remains unsolved. The case becomes a famous unsolved mystery, with no explanation for how the murders were committed or who the killer was.