The Theme of Good and Evil

The exploration of the nature of good and evil in the novel, particularly through the characters of Cathy, Cal, and Adam.

increasingBearing stren­gth in each eventdecreasing

The Monster of Cathy

The Inhuman Evil The Born Monster Cathy is portrayed as a monster from birth. She lacks a conscience. She is said to be 'malformed' in her soul. This raises the question of whether evil is innate. The Manipulation of Sexuality Cathy uses sex as a weapon. She is cold and calculating. She derives pleasure from power and cruelty, not from intimacy. The Inability to Love Cathy is incapable of love. She sees others as tools. Her life is a series of destructive acts. She is the embodiment of pure evil in the novel.

The Struggle in Cal

The Inherited Tendency The Fear of His Mother's Blood Cal fears that he has inherited his mother's evil nature. He sees his own cruelty and manipulation as proof of this. He is terrified of becoming like her. The Choice of Good Despite his fears, Cal is capable of good. He loves his father and wants to be loved. He makes genuine efforts to be kind. His struggle is the central conflict of his life. The Moment of Crisis When Cal takes Aron to see Kate, he gives in to his worst impulses. But he immediately regrets it. His guilt shows that he has a conscience. He is not a monster; he is a flawed human being.

Adam's Innocence and Fall

The Good Man The Naive Idealist Adam is a good man, but he is naive. He believes in the goodness of others. He is easily deceived by Cathy's appearance. The Fall into Despair After Cathy's betrayal, Adam falls into a deep depression. He becomes a 'fallow man'. His goodness is not enough to protect him from evil. The Rise Again Through the help of Samuel and Lee, Adam slowly recovers. He learns to accept the world as it is. He finally understands that he must choose to live. His final act of blessing Cal is an act of grace.

The Role of Rejection

The Root of Evil The Rejected Child Lee argues that the story of Cain and Abel is about rejection. Cain is rejected by God, and this leads to murder. The novel explores how rejection can create evil. Cal's Rejection Cal feels rejected by his father. This feeling drives his jealousy and his desperate attempts to win approval. When he is rejected again, he lashes out. The Breaking of the Cycle Adam's final blessing is a rejection of rejection. He gives Cal the gift of acceptance. This breaks the cycle of guilt and allows the possibility of redemption.

The Fallow Man

The Wasted Life The Metaphor of the Land Samuel Hamilton compares Adam's unused land to his unused life. A man who does not cultivate his life is like a fallow field, overgrown with weeds. Adam's Paralysis After Cathy leaves, Adam allows his life to go fallow. He does not work, he does not love, he does not engage with the world. He is a 'fallow man'. The Call to Cultivation Samuel's advice to Adam is to 'go through the motions'. He must act as if he were alive, and eventually the feeling will come. This is a call to take responsibility for one's own life.

The Power of Choice

The Freedom of Man The Hebrew Word Lee's discovery of the word 'Timshel' is the culmination of the novel's philosophical theme. It means 'thou mayest', not 'thou shalt' or 'do thou'. It is a choice, not a command. The Responsibility With choice comes responsibility. Man cannot blame his sins on his father or his mother or his genes. He must choose for himself. This is the burden and the glory of being human. The Final Gift Adam's final word to Cal is 'Timshel'. It is a gift of freedom. It tells Cal that he is not condemned to be evil. He can choose to be good. This is the novel's ultimate message of hope.

Cathy's character as a study in evil, 1870s-1918

Cal's internal battle between good and evil, 1900-1918

Adam's journey from innocence to experience, 1860s-1918

The theme of rejection as a cause of evil, 1900-1918

The concept of the 'fallow man' – a life unlived, 1900-1918

The central theme of 'Timshel' – 'thou mayest', 1901-1918