The Swamp of Japan
Silence (Library Edition)The metaphor of Japan as a swamp that kills Christianity.
increasing
Bearing strength in each event
decreasing
Ferreira's Swamp

Ferreira's Swamp
The Analogy
Ferreira said Japan is a swamp where the sapling of Christianity rots. The Japanese twist the faith into something else.
The Butterfly in the Web
He compared Christianity to a butterfly caught in a spider's web: only the skeleton remains.
Significance
Inoue's Explanation

Inoue's Explanation
The Root Cut
Inoue said the roots of Christianity were cut. The sapling withered. The God of the peasants had changed.
The Swamp Prevails
He claimed that Japan cannot absorb Christianity. The cultural swamp defeats the foreign religion.
Significance
Meeting at Saishoji, September 1638
After Rodrigues' apostasy, 1638