Readify

Beatrice tells Emma she has set Christmas as her suicide deadline

Up

Beatrice tells Emma she has set Christmas as her suicide deadline in a conversation that turns an awkward attempt at sympathy into a disclosure of imminent danger. At sixty-four, after months of depression and treatments she believes have failed, Beatrice says she has promised her family she will wait until 24 December. Her insistence that she is not suicidal sits uneasily beside that deadline: the scene makes clear that a person’s own description of risk and the practical danger of a stated plan do not necessarily align.

The conversation and its disclosure

Emma asks Beatrice whether seeing her grandchildren the previous evening was enjoyable. The question lands badly. Beatrice says that she has been depressed for three months and admitted against her will, and asks how she could still enjoy anything. Emma tries to explain that, in her own depression, feeling can disappear; a visit may at least distract her even when she cannot tell whether she enjoys it. Beatrice’s answer is sharper: seeing her family makes her want to die.

She explains that even the inability to enjoy her grandchildren confirms, for her, that life is no longer worth continuing. Her family knows this, she says, and she is in the hospital for their sake rather than her own. She has told them that if she is still depressed at Christmas, she will end her life. Having already endured a three-month depression and then entered another, she no longer believes that the episode will pass. The deadline is specific: her family has until 24 December to help her; after that, she says, she will act herself.

Emma’s first response is to ask whether this plan explains Beatrice’s admission. Beatrice rejects the label of being suicidal, recalling that a psychiatrist had made that judgment and that she was consequently placed on the locked ward, against what she understood to be the arrangements. She says she will do nothing before 24 December, but that the date is the limit for everyone who still thinks they can make her better. The distinction Beatrice draws does not remove the risk; instead, it reveals how strongly she treats the promised delay as a boundary around her decision.

Depression, time, and failed treatment

Beatrice describes a recent chain of care that has not restored her hope. Over roughly a month and a half, she says, her family took her from a general practitioner to a psychologist and then a psychiatrist. When the medication did not work, she left after a week. Her family then asked her to give the PAAZ one more chance, bringing her to the ward where she speaks with Emma. Beatrice experiences each unsuccessful intervention not as evidence that more time may be needed, but as proof that nothing has changed.

Emma cautiously suggests that treatment can take time before its effects become clear. Beatrice answers that time does not exist in the same way during depression. She says she faces each day only by struggling through to the next, and that the promise to her family is what has kept her from acting immediately. For her, time is not a neutral interval in which recovery might occur; it is an enemy that prolongs suffering while offering no credible future. Her deadline therefore gives shape to an experience in which the future has otherwise collapsed into the present pain.

The conversation later informs Emma’s own reflection as she waits outside Rajid’s room. She recognizes the force of Beatrice’s claim that depression abolishes time and contrasts it with mania, in which the present seems to expand until past and future recede. In depression, she thinks, the past and future are swallowed into a single field of despair. This is not simply agreement with Beatrice’s proposed course of action. It is an acknowledgment that Emma had underestimated the way depression can make waiting feel impossible.

Family, obligation, and the ward

Beatrice’s account of family support is conflicted. She says her relatives visit, but not all of them, and she doubts that they come because they want to. She has sacrificed her life for her family and, as she puts it, even postponed her death for them; she now experiences that sacrifice as having brought little comfort. Earlier, Emma had heard that the group seemed relieved when Beatrice returned from a family visit, and she had struggled to know how to approach her. The disclosure helps explain why an ordinary question about grandchildren can meet with such hostility: family contact is not automatically a source of pleasure or reassurance for Beatrice.

The scene also takes place within the ward’s social life, where patients try to interpret one another’s distress with limited knowledge. As Beatrice walks away across the small bridge to speak with Bas about an appointment with the doctor, Linda remains behind and waves to Emma. Emma returns the wave, grateful for the interruption. Linda observes that Beatrice has this effect on others. Emma is left with irritation, concern, and helplessness together, rather than a clean sense of how to help.

Significance and aftermath

The disclosure makes the gap between stated intent and risk a central problem. Beatrice denies being suicidal because she has agreed to wait, yet she has also named a date, described a repeated depressive episode, and said she no longer believes recovery is possible. The ward’s concern is therefore not contradicted by her denial: the deadline itself establishes a serious danger even as Beatrice frames it as a promise kept for her family.

That tension resonates with Emma’s own earlier crisis. She had accumulated medication and planned to take it all at once; Rajid later explains to Sergei that leaving those supplies accessible would make it possible for Emma to act within minutes rather than after days spent visiting pharmacies. In both situations, care cannot rest only on whether a person accepts the description of being suicidal. Access to a chosen means, a defined time limit, and the conditions that might shorten the distance between thought and action matter too. The book does not present Beatrice’s disclosure as a resolution: it leaves Emma with a clearer understanding of her fellow patient’s despair, but also with the uncomfortable knowledge that empathy cannot by itself make the deadline disappear.