The Conflict Between Reason and Faith

William's rational approach versus Jorge's dogmatic faith, culminating in their debate in the finis Africae.

increasingBearing stren­gth in each eventdecreasing

William's Rationalism

The Power of Logic Deductive Method William relies on observation and logic to solve the mystery. He believes in the power of human reason to uncover truth. Skepticism William is skeptical of supernatural explanations. He questions the existence of the Devil's direct intervention. He trusts evidence over authority. The Limits of Reason By the end, William admits that his reasoning led him astray. He acknowledges that the universe may not have an order that human reason can grasp.

Jorge's Dogmatism

The Guardian of Truth Absolute Certainty Jorge of Burgos believes that the truth is fixed and revealed. He sees any questioning as heresy. He is willing to kill to protect his version of truth. Fear of Laughter Jorge fears that laughter undermines the fear of God. He believes that the second book of Aristotle's Poetics is dangerous because it could justify mockery of sacred things. The Final Debate In the finis Africae, William and Jorge argue about the nature of truth. Jorge is unyielding. His fanaticism leads to the destruction of the library.

Throughout the story

Throughout the story